I would say that 90% of offers today cannot handle vertical scaling. Oh yeah? Yeah. Pedro Andrade, one of the biggest traffic managers for direct response in the market. He has already managed more than 35 million Brazilian reais in ads and created the largest direct traffic community focused on Facebook ads in the world. Before you write off this offer for vertical scaling, you need to do a test that I call the budget limit. I'm giving away all the gold here. Give it all away, man. Spill it, spill it, man. I'm talking about a budget ceiling test. Bro, nobody has ever even heard of this. My traffic method, which I've used to scale all projects to six and seven figures, they followed a pattern of three pillars. If you follow these three pillars, as we'll discuss today, it's practically impossible not to scale a direct traffic, direct response project on Facebook ads. This podcast is going places. Imagine I'm a beginner traffic manager and I want to scale an offer, but I don't just want to casually scale an offer. I want to scale hard. I want to change my life. What's the first thing I should do? I always say, if you tested the recent creatives and had low assertiveness, and you run the test differently than what I'm sharing here, retest these creatives in CBO because I'm sure they will validate. Man, it's a sure thing. Oh, I'm going to drop a secret here, man. I like that. Go ahead, bro if you just replicate this scaling structure in a new account, it's unlikely to work. You will probably take a loss every day, and what I did to solve this that really addressed this issue so this is a cool little hack that'll prevent you from losing a lot of money in this lateralization, guys. There's only one important thing: okay, everyone. Clap it up. Hey everyone, welcome to another episode of the podcast, Secrets of Scale, which is the podcast of VTurb. If you don't know VTurb, it's a video hosting platform 100% focused on sales videos. The biggest players in Brazil use VTurb for their sales videos, like G4 Educacao, Novo Mercado, and Misha's Escola do Perpetuo. And also outside Brazil, for example, Mindvalley. The world's largest info product company, they make over 1. 5 billion Brazilian Reais per year. So, if they trust VTurb, you should too. Try VTurb for your business for your sales video, and that's why I left a link where you'll get 15% off for two months. In the comments, just click the link. Create your VTurb account. and the discount will be automatically applied. This is an incentive for you to try VTurb, apply it to your business, and boost your sales video's revenue, just like the top players in the Brazil. billion marketer doing, okay? And besides that, when you create your account, I'll also give you training called optimizing your sales video so you can apply it and make it sell much more than it does. today with the lessons we have there. But besides helping you boost your conversion with VTurb, we also have the Secrets of Scale podcast, where I help you increase your conversion in other ways. Hope you like it, and thanks. Hey, bro, thanks for the invite, man. It's an honor to be here, welcome man! An honor the world's biggest direct response podcast. Nice it just might be, you know, I don't think there's another one like it, right? I'm not aware of any. Guys, if you know another good direct marketing podcast, not just in Brazil, but abroad too, especially abroad, because in Brazil, I'd likely already know. Let me know in the comments, all right? But I don't think so, man. I guess we, I don't know any man. So bro, thanks for taking the time you set aside for us to come here. And I'd love for you to tell people, the few who might not know you, because well, you're not that famous, and I want you to become even more so. So tell everyone a bit about Pedro Andrade, what you do, what you're good at, Great. Well, first of all, thank you so much for the invitation. I'm really happy to be here. And basically, my name is Pedro Andrade, and I come from the Econ. market. I've already managed around 10 million Brazilian reais in e-commerce traffic before moving into direct traffic. direct response, actually. And I tried to scale a traffic agency. I even had 40 e-commerce clients back then. And I saw that it's a very difficult business to scale, a lot of headaches, very little money. You know, I wanted to make real money. And in 2022, I made the decision to switch to direct traffic. I leveraged all my screen time experience in e-commerce, adapted the entire methodology I used for e-commerce. And I created a new detailed methodology for people to run ads in on Facebook. And since then, I created TDA, which I believe today is the largest direct traffic community focused on Facebook ads in Brazil. We've reached 1, 000 active members this year, a completely organic product. I never ran paid traffic for it. And besides that, I've scaled several direct traffic projects in Brazil and worldwide. For both info products and nutraceuticals, using precisely this methodology that I teach. On the TDA. You're kind of like everyone's secret weapon there, who's always in the background, in the back office. Yeah, behind the scenes, you know, as the launch people say. Exactly. For quite some time, I partnered with several big copywriters in the market. I've had project partnerships with Derek, with Poshaw, even Tiago Filemon. We ran some projects together a while back. Ah, Thiagao, right? He's terrible at FIFA. Oh, is he bad at FIFA? Wow, awful. So terrible, man. He got beat up a lot. Man, he's as good at copy as he is bad at FIFA. They're polar opposites, and he really knows copy. He's good at copy. I'm the one who trained man. I trained him Man, I ran so many simultaneous projects back then. At one point, I think I was running seven offers with different ad copies. Damn it, man. That was late, early 23, because this all happened for a specific reason, you know? Even back then, the pain point of traffic acquisition was really intense, especially in direct response. And people had really excellent copy. You know, they had great offers. But for some reason, they just couldn't scale because of traffic. And the first project I got into, it just worked out really well. Then I became known, I think the word spread among the copies, hey, that guy, he knows how to scale. So people started coming to me saying, hey, let's do a project together. And man, I think that was the hardest I'd ever worked because imagine running seven simultaneous offers as a traffic manager, right? That's not an operational role. So. That was the period when I learned everything I know. When I truly managed to master direct response traffic, which is completely different from e-commerce. It's a world, I mean, diametrically opposite. The way to optimize campaigns, the metrics primarily. It was then, because of the sheer volume of projects I was managing, that I was able to really master this skill. So you mentioned that you You have this whole background in e-commerce, right, man, where you were generating those 10 million in traffic and spend. And then later on, you said you migrated from e-commerce over to direct response. You made that shift in your mind because, according to what I gathered, it just wasn't being very profitable for you. The returns weren't great. So, man, nowadays, do you believe that this is the right way? Without a traffic manager, should he start already focused on this direct response approach, or should he start, I don't know, maybe with local traffic, you know, or with something else like that? Something, I don't know, from that thing, what's it called, from Subido, from the side, Sobral, those kinds of things. Man, I truly believe that today, direct response is a significant loophole in the system, in the matrix, and there is no superior market for a traffic manager than direct response. Well, because. If a manager takes on a project today and secures 10% co-production, which isn't absurd. And then lands an offer that makes, say, 300, 000 REs a month, which honestly isn't much in our market. Man, that person will already be earning $30, 000 a month. For a traditional traffic manager earning $30, 000 REES net a month, man, that's a lot of work. You really need to have a truly structured agency with employees and so on. So, direct response, I think it's a market where you really have to learn traffic the traditional way, which nowadays you can even learn how to do on YouTube, right? How to set up a campaign. What exactly a pixel is, learn about all the metrics, what a CPC, a CTR, a CPM is, and especially how to deal with these metrics when they're outside of the usual standard. And then move straight into direct response, right? And direct response, it really opens up a very broad range of options for the manager. Because if this person says, 'No, I don't have any kind of profile for solo entrepreneurship. I don't want to run an offer.' This guy, he can enter a structured operation that will also provide resources and the possibility for him to scale and earn as a manager within it. So, you know, I know operations managers who earn $90, 000 res a month with commissions from all the D. So it's a market with a lot of money circulating. It's a market that's really booming. I believe the direct response market in Brazil is still quite embryonic, with much room to grow. Fucking much. If you compare the market in 2022 to now, Holy shit. That's something else, right? It's not even that, man. I'm old school. Damn. Back in 2018, the market was just this. Nowadays, there are so many people with very-We were, man, uh, we were out with some folks, went for lunch, and a kid just came up to me. Okay, look, Anderson He said he sold stuff on the street, didn't he? He sold things on the street and was saving money to start testing offers. Exactly. It's at that level, you know? They're like this. Joao is famous, guys. Um, Maybe he asked for photos. He asked for a photo, right? So you see, Anderson, I'm doing nothing here. Go with your new best friend. See if he'll take pics with folks. He's famous, Anderson. Yeah. But then, man, the business expanded greatly. Grew much. And this will definitely give you more money without a doubt because the traffic manager always captures a percentage of the value they generate. With an offer, if you're working in a direct marketing operation, the value is very high because businesses scale so much. They climb much. It doesn't just scale a lot. It scales very, very fast. So for e-commerce, making $300, 000 a month usually takes time, right? But with direct traffic, if you nail the offer, it's quick. To get results. Hey everyone, before you continue with the podcast, I just wanted to thank you all. Because we've made some progress, we've reduced the number of people who aren't subscribed to the VTurb channel. That number today is at 59. 2%. You'll see the screenshot on screen, and before, it was 65%. So, dude, thank you so much. Okay. This is really helping us grow our channel more. Our goal here is to reach 50% of the people who watch our videos subscribe to the channel. So, if you have, if you haven't subscribed yet, just click below and subscribe. You've nothing to lose. In fact, you'll only gain from it, because more subscribers mean channel growth, allowing us to bring bigger guests. With even better content for you to enjoy. So you've nothing to lose, only to gain. Just click below, okay? Help us reach our goal of 50% of the people watching the channel as subscribers. Thank you very much and enjoy the podcast. Yeah, e-commerce needs to generate branding. It needs to build a brand for it to make money today. A traditional e-commerce, right? To make $300, 000 raise a month, that's already a big structured e-commerce. With an established brand. So that's a process of years. In direct response, a person enters a project, validates an offer this week, and next week they'll be scaling $300, 000 a day if it's a really good offer. So, and in direct response, more than in any other market, and it should be like this in all of them. The manager is a performance professional, right? So he earns based on what he generates. The thing is, in other markets, like the launch market, it used to be this way. Back in 2014, 2015, managers would secure really good deals. Then they become the expert strategist. But man, I remember managers back then closing co-production deals for 30, 40% with experts, no investment needed. Just to generate traffic, to acquire- new leads. Consequently, many managers back then became multimillionaires through the launch market. However, this trend gradually faded because I observed a very strong movement within the launch market. Where major experts started to internalize all aspects of their operations. So the traffic manager stopped being a strategist and essentially became an employee of the expert. So today I know managers who, uh, handle millions in traffic for launches and they get a fixed salary of $5, 000, for example. Now, in direct response, that usually doesn't happen unless you're a junior or something like that. But you'll always earn proportionally to the results you generate. Man, this is talking about service provision within direct response, right? Uh-huh. If you're a manager who you don't necessarily have to be a bold one, but if you understand who studies this market as a whole. and knows how to run an offer. then the manager's scale is just unlimited. And. When I first got into the market, you know, it's actually pretty funny because I got in when I found out about direct response back then with PLR and everything, all the content said, look, the 90-10 of this whole thing is the offer. So what did I do? I went to learn about offers. So I entered the market wanting to study and copy, not traffic. And the first product I bought back then was Copy Classics. I don't know if you know this product by Gabriel Constantino. I know, it's a community, right? Man, I was so lucky that like This product, I say, I thank Gabriel even today. Like this product, I believe, has changed my life. Because man, I could have fallen into any top of funnel content and that would have really delayed my journey in the market. And I remember I was just randomly searching on Google. I remember I typed, 'how to learn copy for direct traffic.' That was something I searched for. So. Man, I was just searching, scrolling through Google search bar, and I found Gabriel's sales page like second to last. It was ranked, well, not too badly. But it was on the first page, way at the bottom. Then I thought, 'Wow,' I clicked. The sales page copy was really good. So then I saw that he was delivering summaries of classic copywriting books. And I said, 'Well, this is what I need, right?' I need to understand the theory behind it and then start writing my own copies. And then I got into this product and it had weekly calls. That's where I first met Derek. Back then, Derek made a call and I said, 'Damn, who's this kid?' Derek looks like a kid. He was only 16, already closing deals. I thought, man, I'm diving into this world. Look at this kid. And that's when the frustration really hit, because I came from traffic management, which is a totally analytical field. And with copywriting, you really need to understand human behavior. It's not something that you can master in just a short amount of time. The learning curve for copywriting, it is absolutely massive. And unlike traffic, which you can learn and master much more quickly. So what's the deal? I said, I'll start writing some VSLs, see what happens. And I tested back then, man, I remember trying some, dude, no exaggeration, like 14. offers and I didn't get anything right like the offer that worked best. I must have made about four sales. I said, man, this isn't for me, is it? And then I said, look, I need to make a decision here. Either I dive in and learn copywriting or I don't know, I'll just leave the market. It was so crazy. I was a traffic manager. I had already managed 10 million reads in traffic. For e-commerce, and back then, it never crossed my mind like man I can make money doing traffic in this market right and then one day it just clicked I said man why don't I go after partnerships to start running these projects but as a manager so what did I start doing I started buying every single copy product that was launched. I would buy it. By then, I was already taking part in the Copy Classics program. I purchased Tiago Filemon's Clothes. Friends program. I purchased every single one of Derek's workshops. I bought Bakuda's Close Friends Group and what did I do I wasn't I didn't buy these mentorships to learn copy it was just to join the group and connect with the people who were into copy so What was my strategy? I wasn't just grabbing people. That scoundrel, folks. You are so dirty. It was a subtle prospecting. You know, what did I do? Look, since it was a copy group and they knew nothing about traffic, any traffic question they posted in the groups, I answered. I had pinned all four groups, and if traffic came up, I was the one answering. I became like the group's support when it came to traffic. And then I remember one day, man, some guy asked about traffic, like, and Bakuda tagged me in the message without even knowing me. Bakuda had never spoken to me. He tagged me and said, 'bro, do you know what this could be?' So I replied, and then I became known among copywriters as someone who understood traffic. And then one day I got to, but until then, I had never landed any project, right? And then I said, man, I need to be more aggressive, right? I said, I'm going to send a message here in the groups saying I'm a traffic manager. I've managed so much. And if anyone has an offer available to run, I can join the project. And then I did that. And who calls me? Mr. Poshaw. The first offer I managed traffic for was Poshaw's, an extra income offer. And man he called me and said, 'Dude, my manager abandoned me. We've got this small offer here. It's validated. Let's run with it. So I said, 'All right, let's do it. What's your proposal for me Then man, right away, he said, 'Dude, 70, 30, let's do it.' And I said, 'holy crap, man, I can't believe it.' What kind of market is this, dude? Man, the guy offered me 30% upfront without me saying anything. I was expecting like 5% for co-production. I'd be happy. He offered me 30%. I said, 'man, let's do it.' And so we started that project. I gave my all there. And that was so crazy, man. It seems like God liked giving me this insight to say, 'no, I can make money with traffic in this market because man, you try 14 VSLs writing copy. It doesn't work. In the first project, you enter as a manager, which is like what you know how to do, you already succeed. So we made some money with that offer. That's where I really managed to apply what I was already training and adapting my e-commerce knowledge to the direct response market. With that offer, everything just clicked. It worked out great. We managed to scale this project. We didn't scale this project. Mostly Poshaw's fault, you see, because he was then he was lazy. He didn't write ads. Back then, you know, you could insult Poshaw. He'd find it less bad than asking him to write something creative. So we ended up, man, right. It was the era of absurd plagiarism. You'd launch an offer and the next day it was copied. Yeah. We ended up losing that offer because people plagiarized a lot, but that project opened all the doors for me. I think my name spread in the market. They said, 'That guy knows how to scale.' And that's where I started these partnerships with all these copywriters. And that's where, in fact, because I handled a large volume of projects, I began to see my method worked for any offer. So that's when I said, 'Wow, there's a whole world here.' This really works to validate any direct response offer. And that's exactly what happened. So that's where I developed the entire methodology for creative testing, for pre-scaling. You know, I was the first in the market to say, 'creative tests don't validate offers, man.' Pre-scaling validates offers. Because what often happens? You'd test creatives. Sometimes that offer worked for several creatives with like five ROAS. But when you put the budget into pre-scaling, it died, it lost money. And this happened quite frequently. I used to say, if the guy is good at copy, it's highly unlikely that he'll launch a creative test and not get any sales from it. Right. So while the copies were good with a small budget and a very good ROAS they lost traction when you scaled the budget. So I thought I need to add another step to our validation process for this. So what do I usually say? Creative testing doesn't validate the offer. Creative testing validates the creative. There's another step to truly validate the offer and see if it will really gain traction for scaling. Man, you're awesome, aren't you? We've already got one, two, three, four, five, six questions. This podcast is going places. Shit man, we're fucked. We'll be here all day for this. Dude. First question. All right. So you mentioned you went there to that community, right? The copy classics one. And I'm a copywriter, as you probably know, right? And for me, it was absolutely essential to study the classics. I don't think it's the most efficient thing to do. I think it's kind of arduous process, you know? There are methodologies out there that teach you advanced copy, like specific copy, but it shows you, hey, do this. You'll know how to do it, but you won't grasp the principles, right, of the business. But since I like to truly understand the principles, to get to the bottom of things, for me, it was really worth it. Even if it took longer, even if it wasn't 80-20, I think it's good. So my question is, just like there are these copy classics, do you think there are kind of the traffic classics? Well. Because you have this e-commerce background, right? Wouldn't e-commerce traffic be kind of the classic, like the essential thing for a traffic manager? Not that they need it to get results. They don't, but for them to be, let's say, complete, would you think so? Totally. This analogy, like it's bizarre because it's so true. You know, I usually say that the e-commerce manager. He has a certain ease to migrate to direct response. Because the traffic manager who comes from e-commerce, he's already used to generating conversions. And I find the traffic managers who come from e-commerce more analytical. So like, and another thing as well, right? The entire school of Facebook traffic, when we talk about conversion specifically, it originated in e-commerce, e-commerce, or drop shipping. So in the United States, the biggest traffic experts, let's put it this way, they all come from e-commerce. So these are the guys who, you know, manage like 300 million Brazilian reais every month. So they create some content, even though actual traffic content is quite scarce, you know. Like really solid content. But honestly, I think the classic school of traffic on Facebook, I'm sure, comes from e-commerce. And I see this as a truth because I see these e-commerce managers excelling in other markets as well when they migrate, right? Whether it's for direct response or for a launch, because it's very different, man, from when you need to drive traffic that converts, where someone has to pull out their credit card and pay, versus, for example, running a lead capture where the person just signs up with an email on a link, boom, that's a Facebook conversion. The metrics analysis is completely different. In e-commerce, you already need to start looking at checkout conversion rates. So this creates a certain toughness in the manager, like. Man, I can't just blow money here without generating results. And that's the pillar of the direct response, right? No doubt. Yeah, put 100 REs here, man. It needs to make 150, 200. Otherwise, we're losing money. Otherwise, it's wrong, right? Well, so the e-commerce manager already comes with this. perspective, this vision of the market, like I need to generate results. And generally, the person who's say in local business or even a law. since the conversion is different. It takes time for them to grasp that concept, that whole experience, man. It's about, I need to generate revenue results. Invested X, I got Y, that's what I need to do, and replicate the e-commerce manager already comes prepared in that sense. So that's why I say e-commerce is such a strong foundation for traffic, and that's why those guys have an easier time in the direct response market. So I really believe in that idea that it's comparable to the classics of copywriting and the classic of traffic is e-commerce. That's interesting, man. What else do you think? Is so different. That people should learn from e-commerce. What do you believe e-commerce teaches that makes it so essential? I know you've already mentioned that part, you know, being more analytical and being careful not to just blow money on silly things, right? Actually running that campaign, and him being responsible for the outcome. I know this is man, it's essential. Is there anything else you think is very important, or how do you view this? Dude, it does. I think I often say that e-commerce, it's the basis of, how do I put this? E-commerce is the benchmark. In terms of online conversion. So I think e-commerce, it dictates the rules for everything sold online. So for example, this checkout model that we know today from platforms. It was based on platforms like MercadoLibre, for example, and Amazon. So e-commerce brought this checkout standard to the market. And man, I think practically everything, when comparing e-commerce and direct response, for example, page loading speed is something extremely important in both direct response and e-commerce. Offer, mainly, because what truly converts in e-commerce is the offer. Which is a combination of factors there. So the offer in e-commerce is, as people usually say, everything from the product's photo, the product's description, the price, shipping, delivery method. So all these factors put together make up the e-commerce offer. If you don't have a well-rounded offer, for example, if you get everything right, but the price wrong, you won't have an offer that converts well. So this whole idea of seeking, of isolating these variables to build a good offer, that comes from e-commerce. And I see this very strongly in direct response too. Checkout conversion is the same thing, you know, measuring the page sections. I think all of this definitely comes very strongly from e-commerce. Drawing this parallel with the direct response market. So e-commerce is always dictating the rules in this sense of online sales in general. In practice, the people watching us here and all. Man, even me, right? When I started, I was an affiliate. I also ran traffic on Facebook back then. You can tell us more about that later, it's funny. But in practice, man, the truth is that people, they're not going to do e-commerce, you know? The folks watching us here, they want to run their own offer. They want to put, just like a guy who wants to write a VSL, he's not going to study the classics. Yeah, maybe some of you will, okay? Some of you folks, you'll go and study and all that. Cool, awesome, congratulations, well done. But the vast majority, they'll want to cut corners. They'll just want to do what? What really works, you know? So, do you think there's a way for someone to gain this classical foundation, but without actually running e-commerce? Another way to phrase this is: how exactly does one properly study traffic? How does a person truly learn traffic? The correct way you know learn so that you can truly become a real badass, scale well, and have strong, good principles there. Look. I think if a manager today wants to work in the direct response market, and identifies this early, I believe the best path for them is to learn the basics of traffic on YouTube, for example. By 'basics,' I mean launching a campaign, creating a pixel. The hands-on part, pressing buttons. Yes, pressing the buttons, understanding what an ad manager is, and the important metrics. What would I do today? I would learn it this way and I would affiliate myself with a product that is, you know, direct traffic, meaning I'd affiliate with an info product. Or perhaps a nutraceutical, because what truly makes a difference in the person's day-to-day experience is the analysis of metrics. By running as an affiliate, he'll already have this metric analysis. He'll start to pick up the metric patterns of creatives that convert and scale, right? Ah, he'll start to see the metric patterns of the niches. So he'll say, 'Man, I'm running a weight loss product here.' The standard CPC for this niche here in Brazil is, say, 220. He sees he uploaded a creative where he targeted the wrong audience, that CPC is at three. 'Man, he'll already know that this metric is off, that he needs to change the hook of that creative, maybe.' So it's this screen time that, 'man,' you only get by actually running traffic. Sometimes, 'man,' copy, let's put it this way. A guy can get really good in theory. So you take a guy who studied all the classics but never wrote a VSL. You talk to him about copy. That guy will know everything. Me, for three years. It was me. That was me, guys. Yeah, this guy will know everything. He'll quote chapter eight of 'Make Peace' from top to bottom. You know, this chapter is good. This chapter is great. Study it, everyone. It's a game changer. The ABC process to make your copy invincible. It's right here, dropped into the head. I did study, you know, to know chapter eight as a traffic manager, I studied the classics. Man, for you to know that, you're, see folks, actually, he's not even a traffic manager. He's a copywriter. That's why he succeeded and is here. Got it? This damn traffic doesn't work, this crap. Thank you. Hey, sorry to interrupt your podcast, okay? I just wanted to give you a super quick message. Dude, if you have a sales video, then you need to host this video here on VTurb. VTurb is not only the best sales video host thanks for watching. Man, and so assuming, right, that someone's gonna, gonna start, okay? They'll learn this initial part. Then you mentioned we can form these partnerships with these people, right? Like, hey, I'll run traffic here for you and so on. And then you said that, well, Poshaw, right? For those who don't know Poshaw, folks, just think of a crazy guy. He's crazy, dude. Did you know Poshaw is jacked, man? But he's ripped without even working out, man. He's got godlike genetics. Poshaw is so awesome, man. He's totally ripped, guys. He's jacked and hasn't trained in two years, man. No guys, this guy's nuts. That dude is insane. But anyway, uh, he offered you 30% there, right? I wanted to understand man how these contracts are like how people negotiate these things, yeah. Generally, does it stay in that 30% range? 20% or like, how does it work for the guys who are in for the managers interested in this? They want to do more of this. Look, it really depends. If a manager has the cash to operate, so if he has some initial capital there, he can form these partnerships, for example, like let's do 70-30 and I'll invest proportionally. So you invest 70, I invest 30, and you become a project partner. That's still widely practiced in the market today. Now, a manager with no cash, like one entering the market with nothing, they'll take smaller co-productions. So maybe 5% of the gross, maybe 10, 15% of the net that offer generates without needing to invest, which is very good too. So today, the two most common approaches practiced in the market are these. Either the manager invests proportionally to their ownership percentage and takes a higher share. Or they take a lower percentage of the profit. Or even from the gross revenue of the co-production, but this percentage is lower. But even so, we're talking about a lot of money. Man, a million Ries a month as an offer isn't something extraordinary. You know, it's something nowadays I'd even say that revenue is average. So bizarre. That's why we say, man. It's the direct response. Honestly, I think it's still a bit above average, right? But back then, a million was like, 'Wow, holy crap, what is that? Like, my god, seven figures a month. Well, back then, market giants made multiple six figures, right? Today, man, a guy joins the market two months ago, hits an offer, he's making a million a month. Some even then. That day. Some guys are doing. Today, the market in the States, man, that thing is doing this in a day. So it's insane. But how does this guy manage to find these opportunities? Right? For copywriters, you had your own little hack of getting into groups and doing that networking. Do you think that still works today? Or do you think there are other ways to prospect these copywriters to become your partners? Dude, I think I'd choose the same path even today because our market, it's a very closed one. You know, that's just a fact really. People simply don't trust each other. And that's fair, because the market itself created this whole culture of plagiarism, you know, and the manager is the one who will have access to the entire funnel, right? So there's no client prospecting in this market. You can't just walk in and say, 'Well, I'm gonna prospect for copywriters here.' That simply doesn't exist. So the way you're going to prospect for these offers is through relationships. It's really about building relationships. So I do exactly the same thing. You need to be where the copywriters are. So you have to build relationships, show him you're trustworthy, that you won't plagiarize or steal his offer. And I would do it this way. So I think that's the easiest way for you to start in this direct response market. To get access to traffic, like to start running specific traffic for direct response, right? Because look, if you don't practice, man, if you don't run direct response traffic, you won't learn. You won't master it. Yes, certainly. So that's what I would do. I would start with the affiliate experience just to get some learning in, you know? Well, all right. I've gathered all the metrics. But I don't want to run offers for myself. I want to establish partnerships. So I'd go after those groups, join those networks, those close friends. Well, the thing is, nowadays, the market has changed a lot too. Right, Joao? With all this hype, this whole American market thing. I think a traffic manager can make the transition today. Man, I'm learning to run traffic here as an affiliate in Brazil, like, for example, an info product affiliate. And then he wants to run his own affiliate operation in the United States. Can he do that? You know, if someone wants to go down this path saying, 'no, I want to run my own operation.' I don't want any partnerships. They can already enter the American market because. Like the American market today has taken the burden off the offer, right? So you have access to validated offers. You just need to focus on making good creatives and running traffic, which you're already training for and already know. So, man, that was a tremendous advance for traffic managers. This American market coming in so strong and arriving in Brazil like it did. This will definitely shorten everyone's journey. Yes, without a doubt. If the guy can already get the offer part more guaranteed, right? Then it's, and if he knows traffic, it becomes much, much easier. Yeah, because back then, when this was in 2022, right? When I really started. Man, getting access to a validated offer was incredibly difficult. You just couldn't do it. It was only through these partnerships, but seriously. Think how much money I spent buying these products. They weren't that cheap. I remember Tiago Filemon's close friends. I think I paid $2, 000 Rays. Then Wakuda's was another $1, 400. No, Tiago really gouges you, man. I've told him, man, Tiago's a badass, bro. He's gotta keep his restaurants going, all those things he buys. Oh, the lovely food he posts, right? No, Tiago is just, yeah, his lifestyle is. He's a badass, man. It is. So I think the path for people today is much shorter with this affiliate market booming like it is, you know? Hmm-hmm. And so you know, uh, all of this happens, right? Because the traffic manager is able to generate value for the market as a whole. Uh-huh. And that's interesting, because there's a prejudice in the market, right, that you must know, right, that I even have a bit of it too, I wanted to tell you, so you could break this barrier, this one of mine, because man, for a long time, okay, I always thought traffic was just pushing a button. And I remember we had a traffic manager there at the company back when I had it. And man, we had an offer. We were spending, I think, like 50 per person for an average ticket of 400. Uh-huh. And it was damn good there. I was spending, I was. CPA absurd, right? Yeah, it was excellent. And he'd spend, like, he'd create an ad set, put a thousand Rees to spend, then boom, he'd sell a ton. Eight Rees rice and all that. So I'd say, dude, just add another. zero here. Instead of a hundred thousand, make it ten thousand. Add another little zero. And he said, no, but how can I just add another zero? That's absurd, man. I can't. I said, dude, no, just add the zero, man. And the guy wouldn't add the damn zero. I had to sit by him and say, add the zero. He refused, so I went there, put the zero in, and pressed it. Man. Then overnight, bam, sales just exploded. Uh huh. And so I combined this uh with the fact that I had already run traffic in my time when I ran traffic. It was to set up the campaign, press the button, and let it run. And so in my head, what was traffic? Okay, on Facebook at least. The rest I don't know because I didn't, didn't run it. But in my head, traffic on Facebook was about setting up campaigns, pressing buttons, and having the courage to invest. Having the courage to invest about putting in the money you get it. You need the guts to put the money in there and screw it. So, if you lose it, it's lost. But if it comes back, obviously you're not gonna put money in a campaign that's not giving ROI. My affiliate did that man. What a funny guy. Funny guy. This guy is one of the He funded the campaign. It was in the red. No, he spent it. He said, 'A hundred res, no sale.' He said, 'Dude, I spent a hundred res, no sale.' I'll put 200. So he put 200. What logic did he use? I don't know, man. He put 200 in, sold for 100. He said, 'Damn, it sold.' I put 200 in, got a sale. So what if I put 400? Will it work? And he did. He just kept going, man. Kept adding. Man, this is Mark Zuckerberg's ideal client. Bro, mine too, bro. I saw his sales going up like that. I said, damn, he's a top affiliate, bro, damn. And then, bro, how's it going, you know? Then he said, no, it's, I'm here testing. Overnight, he stopped selling. Boom. So I asked, dude, what happened? He said, no, I failed. I said, what? He was selling a ton. He said, no, I was losing. I said, what? You're losing money. man, right? He had the logic reversed. Yeah. But anyway, I've always had this thing, you know, straight up traffic is just putting the campaign there and hitting the buttons and having the balls, right? To make the business grow. And, look, with all the humility in the world, okay? I'm not a traffic manager. I don't really get it. Uh, I'd like to know what you think about this prejudice. Do you think that at some point this was true? Or was it because the market was amateur and didn't really know what to do? How do you see this whole thing? Man, wow, that's absolutely true. And I can speak to that with some personal experience, you know, a certain amount of personal experience, because as I was a part of these copywriting groups. Man, I'd see the guy's comments about traffic there daily, you know? And the comments from everyone, like there were even some jokes going around in these groups, like, 'if you have a good offer, even a dog can run traffic.' And I think people took it as a joke and all, but. I think that was the sentiment and many copywriters truly believed it because, and actually I even thought that myself because. A good offer really makes traffic much easier right? You don't need to keep creating testing interests, testing various sets; you'll just put it up there and it will sell. The question is, how much will it sell and how much money you'll miss out on? That's what good traffic does, you know? So what happens then? I believe that my greatest contribution to the market wasn't having created this methodology that practically everyone uses today for direct response. But after I launched TDA, people began to see how crucial traffic was. So, about two months after launching TDA, I started receiving a lot of feedback. Pedro, I optimized the area just as you teach. I tested creative. The way you show and overnight my profit tripled so uh there are definitely ways when you're doing good traffic generation you know Bad creatives and a poor offer, I don't think it saves you. But I believe you minimize your risks, so you won't lose money when you might otherwise lose it with bad traffic. And especially when it's good. You can scale much more with a much healthier margin than you would scale without knowing how to do traffic, right? So people started seeing its importance after this methodology. I think traffic went to a whole other level. It began to change this prejudice from that time, you know, July 2023, when I launched it, people really started to see, man, traffic has a certain importance in this market. And if you know how to do it, you'll make more money than you would if you didn't know, right? Even with a good deal. Sure. So man, you managed to triple your profit without needing to change your offer, without needing to change your creative dudes. It's an ideal world, right? Excellent. So I think we've kind of managed to lay the groundwork for this path for traffic managers, right? I felt this very strongly in the feedback from students who were managers. After TDA, they managed to close better contracts within companies. They managed to close better co-production contracts because people are seeing the importance of good traffic in the direct response market, right? And man, I think this really served as like the definitive proof to say, man, traffic is truly important. It came now with the advent of the American market. Right? I have to say it again here because, if you look at the American market, the biggest affiliates in the world are traffic managers, right? The guys come from traffic itself. So I think that really changed things. I think it even would. Today, with the US market, it's evened out, right? Copy and traffic in terms of importance. Hmm. Yeah, regarding this whole direct response funnel situation. Yeah, man. Dude, really interesting. I believed, right? I had this belief, you know, like that, damn, it's just pushing a button and all. And there was a guy who joined my company, right? Who's now in BH. That's Lucas. Lucas Rigo, right? His podcast will show up. Okay, guys? He did a YouTube podcast. Lucas. is awesome. Yeah, man. He's coming to Floripa now. He'll live here. Oh, cool. Lucas taught me in my community, man. At TDA, he teaches YouTube. Oh, cool, right? Lucas is awesome. And man, he joined the company and I saw the difference he made. You know, he got there and bam, he immediately started pushing hard and scaling up the offers that we had. and And I saw the difference, like, damn. A good traffic manager, he's like, he's kind of a catalyst, you know? It's like lighting a, you like to make a barbecue? Uh-huh, bro. He's like a ready-made fire starter, you know? No need to keep adding alcohol, making everyone. Just put it there, and bam. The offer lights right up, makes the barbecue much easier and faster. Yeah, that analogy is perfect, man. Exactly right. Yeah, I see it that way a lot. You know, of course, I don't think it saves a terrible offer, okay? yeah I think he can really help with a mediocre or poor offer, like making it profitable on a medium scale a deal where you'd lose money right. Yeah, exactly. With a losing offer, he can improve its efficiency. But man, a good offer, a good offer even with a poor traffic manager makes money. A good offer with a good traffic manager, you make a lot of money. You change your life. So, um, I guess that's the whole thing. Yeah, dude. And in the past, I think there was this strong belief. Damn, traffic is just pushing buttons because man, I think. It was much easier to nail the offer. So, whatever crap the guy did there, it was already a good offer, and he'd press the button on Facebook, bam, and sell. Man, in my first eye, as an affiliate, right? Without knowing a damn thing about traffic, uh, I was making like three four hundred thousand at home easily, and I'd keep like thirty percent, you know, uh-huh, fine. As an affiliate, perfect. Well, when I became a producer, I remember there was a day, man, that I invested, I think it was six thousand res, yeah, it was six thousand res, and I sold a hundred like how I, yeah, me managing it, there. You know, just casually with a 20% raise, CPA to sell 400 something, so absurd, crazy, huh? So back then, I think it really was a bit more like that, but then, as the copy situation kept getting harder and harder, we have to get more sophisticated in terms of traffic. And nowadays, not just that, but in terms of copy too, right? Because precisely, it's obvious you know, things get harder and then you have to get better and better, uh, to be able to stand out in the market and get results. Yes, the timing in this direct response market is crucial, right? If back then it was because of plagiarism, you had to scale quickly. Nowadays, it's because of market sophistication. Today, it's 10 times harder to nail an offer. 20 times harder to nail a creative that scales. When you hit the mark, dude, your traffic needs to be absolutely flawless and you need to scale up without wasting any time. For you to truly be able to make money. Uh huh. And I see a very strong movement today in the market of the biggest companies, both in Brazil and in the United States, right? That people position as affiliates, as producers anyway, they have a very robust traffic squad, okay? So if you look at the biggest affiliates in the world, for example, they are traffic agencies. In fact, they are traffic agencies. They only have traffic managers. So if you take the top affiliate, well, it's a traffic agency with seven managers. So it's really a very significant volume of traffic and people. Therefore, I see major companies investing increasingly in this because, as I've said, if you accept the offer, well, you need to be fully prepared there to scale up and not lose time because otherwise you will lose that opportunity. So I think traffic comes into this. It's important because of that too, not to lose that timing. And man, what do you think? Um, I wanted to get into right this methodology you have and so on, because like, The traffic manager hits the button. He'll get X, right? Sometimes he'll earn a fixed amount on a million dollar project because that's what he does. That's the value he generates. And so, to negotiate these 20, 30%, sometimes even more than that, right? You need to generate value for the project. You need to deserve that. The project owner, you know, the one. With the offer or maybe a copywriter, he won't give you money for free. Yeah, man, he's not you know doing charity there for sure. So I wanted to understand what these people do differently. You know, so before getting into the methodology itself, I wanted you to explain what you think is the difference man between the guy who just pushes buttons and the one who uh generates more value. What's the 80-20 there? Would it be like decision making, the process of analyzing something, how do you see that? Man, I think the main point is the manager knowing how to communicate with the copywriter or the project owner. Because the traffic manager is the one on the front line for all the metrics. So the copywriter wrote the offer, and from the moment they started testing creatives, the one who's on the front line of the metrics, you know, the one who's getting the market's first response about that offer, is the traffic manager. So the best traffic managers I know are the ones who know how to communicate with the copywriters and the offer owners. So that's why I strongly believe. That the best direct response traffic managers are those who have previously run their own offers because they can have a macro view of the entire sales funnel. So they don't get stuck just on ad manager metrics. So the person who aims to excel as a direct response traffic manager needs to know when a lead is losing too much retention in the first minute, what's a considerable play rate for an offer, what's the retention up to the pitch of a good offer? And what's an acceptable checkout conversion to be able to scale a project like this? All right, so here we're already talking about funnel metrics, strictly speaking, right? But metrics of, for example, from the manager, it knowing when a creative, the hook of that. Creative worked because I'll give you an example not so long ago, actually, quite recently people started paying a lot of attention to the hook rate of creatives, you know, which is the percentage of the hook how many people are watching the first three seconds of the creative. And honestly, six months ago, no one was even talking about this metric. And this is something that I've been observing for a very long time. I even found it strange, you know, people are starting to talk about this now as if it were some huge thing, like, wow. And I thought, come on, that's pretty basic. Because the whole idea of testing creatives, you need to try to increase your accuracy more and more. So for example, sometimes you messed up a creative and that creative didn't scale. For example, it broke even, made some sales, stayed at a breakeven point. The CPA wasn't good enough to scale it. But man, do you really need to throw that creative away completely? So what I saw, what I often saw people doing, was this. The traffic manager gives the following feedback to the copywriter. 'Hey, this creative didn't validate.' That's what the guy says. Nowadays, for example, you might have messed up a creative, the creative broke even, didn't sell, but its hook rate is 80%. Man, you hit that hook really hard. So you can take another body, another creative body, and fit that hook, which could be your winning creative right there. That will generate multiple seven-figure amounts for you. So the good manager, he needs to have this analytical perspective, you know, to look at all these metrics. So CPC, CTR, hook rate, road rate. Which is the percentage of the creative's persuasive core, how much people watch of the whole ad up to 75% of the video, that's used a lot. And. And knowing how to give that feedback to the copywriter. So from there, they can start. We're even talking about offer validation or even scaling. So I believe the main factor for a traffic manager to be good today is having this communication, knowing this. But for the guy to know this, he already needs to have run offers. That's why it's important to sometimes start as an affiliate, to get access to these metrics, otherwise you won't know. Or they join a big operation with a traffic head teaching them, or they'll never get that screen time. You know? Dude. Being an affiliate is a damn good school man, what a great school! Right when you're an affiliate, you learn so much about direct marketing. It's a damn school. It's you and your campaign. You know, that's it. And you have to make it profitable, not just profitable, man, but you have to make it profitable with 50% of the revenue of that product. So like, you have to make it super profitable if you were a producer, you'd have an ROI of four, you know, assuming you've got an ROI of two, there as an affiliate, exactly. Dude, so like it's a thing like this that to be a marketer, there man, it's really good. It's total skin in the game. And I started, when I started with traffic before e-commerce, while I was learning traffic, I started as an affiliate. Me too, bro. I started as an affiliate, went to Hotmart, found products. Then I made some money as an affiliate. Wow. Finding products. And then I used my affiliate results to prospect for e-commerce clients. That's how I first got started in traffic generation. So my mistake, in quotation marks, was transitioning from affiliate marketing to service provision, you know. At that point, I still wasn't familiar with direct response marketing. Right. But it's a mistake in quotes, right? I apply much of what I learned in e-commerce there today. But that was my journey. I started as an affiliate and man, that's skin in the game because it's your money. There if you make a mistake, you're losing cash, you're taking the hit, and you learn ad creation. You learn how to read metrics, you learn everything. Everything man the affiliate market is a crazy school like. For sure. It's crazy how it teaches the person. The affiliate dashboard kind of educates the guy there, you know. Man, that's really something, dude. I remember I used to run a funnel for a weight loss ebook. It was called The Detox Plan from way back then. Yeah, that was quite a while ago. Right. And then I had. A prelander, the funnel was like this. It, uh, grew on Facebook. Then the prelander, which was a quiz, and then a VSL man. The ab testing of headlines I was doing on that quiz, you know. Like, what speeds up your metabolism? Three easy ways to speed up your metabolism just by seeing there. Which I used a plug-in called Hot Links Plus. Plus, okay, if you're old-school, you'll remember that, okay? Hotlinks Plus from Anderson Makai, something like that is the guy's name there. He even made a competitor to VTurb recently, something like that. He's kind of a programmer and all that, and so he had Hotlinks Plus there, and man, damn, that thing there, you could retain, it's kind of a cloaker, you know? He used to filter the traffic, something like that. So I understood then about this part, you know, like what's the CTR of my prelander here, right? The higher the CTR, the more you're going to burn through conversions. And then I was just playing around with these kinds of things. And so, like, man, uh, in programming, there's a term that's called full stack. Which is a person who handles both the front end and the back end of the application. Uh huh. I say there's the same thing in marketing, right? Which is a full stack marketer, a guy who knows traffic and copy. Yes. Dude, if you have a guy who was an affiliate and he knows traffic, knows copy, that guy is a killer. Yeah, for sure. Uh, this guy is the best professional in the market. Yeah, it is like a sniper. I think that's who I am. Man, it's the macro view of the operation, right? For a long time, my business model was to source copy from copywriters, actually. To source the offer from copywriters who didn't have the capital to run it. And what helped me increase that assertiveness to say 'no' I'm going to select this offer to run was my copy knowledge from the copy classics era. So I'd read a sales letter I knew: if it was worth producing, that offer or not, you know. Man, this isn't very well written, you know? And usually I was right, man. Usually the copy I produced and ran brought me results. And that's how I made money in this market. It was with this business model. And this affiliate thing is actually a funny story because the first product I got results from was a Hotmart product. I affiliated with, which was a product for agronomists. It was like marketing and sales for agribusiness. I remember it was that kind of product. And man, I had already mined about 25 products. Like I hadn't gotten any results. Right. And then I said, man, this little product here is cool. Right. It's kind of outside the market's vision, a somewhat unexplored niche. I went made a bunch of. on Canva, started testing and boom, one day I woke up to many sales. So I ran this product for about two months. I recall at the first month's end, I'd invested 4 , 000 REs and 17 , 000 came back. I said, damn, I got rich, man. Now I just need to put more money here and I'll be very rich. I'm the boss. A whole new world, right? So what happened? Then, halfway through the second month, making some good money, I wake up one day to an email from the producer cutting my commission from 70 to 55%. I was like, damn, what the hell, man? I can't run this anymore. Right. So I said, man, what do you mean, dude? Just yesterday, I thought I was rich. I'd made it big online and all, and now there's nothing left. I even emailed the producer saying, dude, don't do this. I'm selling so much. Why are you doing? This? He replied, 'Look, there's no way we're stopping affiliate work and all. And well, this was good because it was with this kind of outcome, like investing three, four thousand and getting seventeen back. That I managed to prospect my very first e-commerce businesses, right? So that's how the affiliate market really helped me. And man, this full stack vision you mentioned, dude, that's so incredibly real. If someone has the opportunity to study copywriting and traffic, Holy shit. That's just insane.' But do you believe that what's better let's say, if you could have a professional like that in your company is it a guy who's like a 10 in copy and like seven and a half in traffic, or seven and a half in copy and 10 in traffic? The guy who's more like more of a copywriter or more traffic you know, he knows both. Can I be frank? Of course. Bro, go on. Man, today, as I'm more involved in the American affiliate market, where I have access to good offers, I would choose the traffic guy. Oh, really? Because. If, especially if this guy has mastered the issue of scale. So I'd have a copywriter not as skilled to write my creatives, right? To save me that work. Because even though it's tough to nail a creative, it's harder to nail a one minute, one and a half minute creative than a one hour VSL script, right? And validate an offer. So this seven and a half copywriter, he'll nail a creative sooner or later. Uh huh. And when he nails it, I'll have this traffic ace to scale and make big money. Bro, I think the skill it's likely to make creative isn't even copy, man. I think it's more. I think it's a market vision. Sure, man. Exactly. It can even get complicated for someone who knows too much copy, you know. Honestly, do you know who I'd hire today to like give me creative ideas and kind of build a backbone? Me. No, for sure. But you're not. Oh man, I'm earning well, so we can negotiate. Thank you. That fee is really high, huh? Man, I'd hire those ad analysis geeks, you know, the guys who spend all day researching ads and seeing what's performing well, because, well, there are some guys obsessed with that, right? Yeah, bro. Some guys grab the spy tool and go, 'Wow, look at this library 400 active ads.' So that guy has market knowledge. He knows everything that's scaling, everything that's working. And. The great thing about creatives is this, their libraries are public, you know, unlike an offer where you might use a cloak and then lack access, often unaware of what's working in that specific offer. With creatives, there's no hiding. So you know exactly what's working and it's easy to replicate. Well, easy in the sense that it's simpler to model a creative that works and understand the structure behind it. For sure, man. So this is a way to boost accuracy. And if you hit, hit, but don't have a good traffic guy to scale, I don't think the operation moves, you know? And sometimes if you have a really good traffic guy, you need one creative. When you have a bad traffic guy, you need 10 to get the same result. I think that's it. That's why I'd go with the traffic guy like that. Yeah, man. I think the traffic guy. He, for making money, he's superior. To feel like a badass, that's the copywriter. A copywriter, he has a huge ego. Yeah, totally. But to make money, man. Because the traffic guy, if he doesn't know much about copy, he won't be judging if it's good or bad. He'll just see, man, does this work or not? It's the metrics, you know? Ah, if this creative scales, it's good. If it doesn't, it's bad. Then he takes that creative and makes more of it. So it's a volume game. It's a game of like, it's all math. The scales and traffic, right? No doubt about it. I understand this big ego of copywriters because copywriters have the ability to make money, you know? Man, he just throws 6, 000 words into a doc, puts money in one end, double comes out the other. Crazy, huh? So it's a truly amazing skill. So I understand it. Dude, I remember when I was running ads. Just listen to what I'm gonna say, folks. Man, the urge I have to go back in time and give myself a beating, man. Grab a pufferfish and bam, a pufferfish smackdown. Losing to a joke. Yeah, because man, it's like I remember, you know, that it was me and the guy who's my partner today, Andre, and then we were running an offer. Man, we were affiliates, uh-huh. And then I look, so we had the same offer. Andre grabbed the copy and launched it, and it was selling it, had a CPA of 70, res to make sales, uh, the average order value was 350, I think, around that. And the commission was 160, more or less. Of course, it varied there, right? Since it was a supplement. So, depending on the bottles. But man, it had a ROAS of two. It was like, great. Awesome. It was just there. I was an affiliate. You thought it bad? It was artist syndrome. Yeah, man. I said no, I'm not running this because it's like, guys, how stupid? Man, I wanted to punch myself. But in the end, it was good, man, because I took that copy and I redid it, and that was my first product, Renova 31, which made us 2. 7 million I got so mad, man, I said, man, I'm not running this shit, no way, I'm running this. So I redid it, added mechanics and all that crap, and then boom, that was the copy for the Egyptian Glue. I don't know if you've heard of it. Yes, yes, it's true. This copy is iconic, right? Yeah, that copy was good, right? And then it sold multiple eight figures. Anyway, copywriters are an arrogant bunch, okay? The amount of people who, oh, Mark's here. Hey, Mark, come on in, man. Hey, everyone, Mark's here, okay? He came to shoot the videos. Come on, Mark, get over here. Hello, dude. Say hi to the camera. Get in this shot. Look there. All good? Well, I had this arrogance, man. I didn't want to go up. What a stupid thing, right? Uh, for you, it was good. Right, you redid it, and it was. But hey, copy is usually lazy. Right. And everyone has a story, like, man, if I'd done that offer, right, I'd be rich. So true. And my story with this, and my story about it, is Poshaw's offer, man. Poshaw's a jerk, dude. Every time I meet Poshaw, I tell him that. Come on, Poshaw. Man, it was like. You'd rather insult Poshaw's mom than ask them to write a creative. And at the time, we were on a pretty good scale. And dude, we scaled the entire revenue of this offer with just one ad. And it wasn't even an ad he wrote. You know what he did? He went to the social proof, the testimonials, cut one out, put a headline on Canva, and that's what he gave me to run. And when I asked him to write new ads, he'd say, 'Oh man, it's making money. Great, just keep going. Before we knew it, 70 copycats were running the same offer, and that was it. No more profit. We completely missed the boat. Poshaw, you would have made me rich. Because of laziness, we didn't get rich with this offer. Thank you. But, man, getting into your part of this methodology thing and all, imagine I am all right, a beginner traffic manager and I want to get in. To scale an offer, right? But man, I don't want to scale an offer just easily. I want to scale the thing really aggressively. I want to like change my life, man. want to scale like five million a month, you know. I want to like sure, just completely reset my life. Yeah, dude. What's the very first thing that I'm going to do? What exactly should I do? Alright, I already know the basics. By the way there are things in the basics that are important for people to pay attention to. For example, you know, is the tracking correct? That's obvious, right? What do you think is the importance of the very basics, like for us to operate effectively? Honestly, to tell you the truth, I think that the entire traffic process, including scaling, is basic. So, because, you know, my traffic methodology, which I've used to scale all the projects I've scaled up until today to multi-six, multi-seven figures, it. Following a pattern of three pillars, which was creative asset testing, pre-scaling, and scaling with area optimization. These three pillars, if you follow these three pillars in the way that we're going to discuss here today, it's practically impossible for you not to scale a direct traffic project, a direct response on Facebook ads. A good traffic, you know, that's assuming the copy is good, isn't it? Exactly. That's what I'm going to say. Good traffic helps you even with that, because if you follow a validated traffic methodology. And well, it didn't sell, you know, you have an offer problem. You can move on to optimizing your funnel, your creatives very calmly because you know. There's no bottleneck in the traffic, you understand? So that's the importance of a good traffic methodology. Just to note this down: creative test, pre-scale, and scale. Daily optimization scale. Okay, I get it. Scale with optimization. Exactly. And what is creative asset testing then, alright? I know the name is quite obvious, but how does it function? How does it actually work in practice? All right, here's the situation. There are two variables. Nowadays, there's a third one, but I'm going to stick to two here. I'll explain the third one later. No, you're going to tell me the third one too, man. You're not leaving without telling me the third one. Is there a fourth one too? No, no, just up to the third. You hide nothing from me. I'm taking that box, okay? Podcast's over now. I'm not gonna give you a present. Here's the secrets to scaling, bro. Here's the thing. First variable in creative testing is The audience segment. So you can have an excellent. Actually, let me start from the beginning, right? So people understand better. Facebook, since it works through auctions, through an auction system to find the winning ad and which audience it's going to show each ad to. It operates through auctions. And this auction is divided into three stages, right? which is the responsiveness of your ad creative, meaning how much the audience that's seeing it reacts to that creative. Anyway, Facebook is very concerned with. User experience: How much it values creative engagement exactly the creative engagement the budget which is meaning how much you bid. So, depending on the budget you set, you'll be directed to auction A or auction B. When you say 'bid,' okay, just so I understand, are you referring to the manual bid or the budget itself? The campaign budget. Is there manual bidding on Facebook? It exists. You can use manual bidding, which actually with Facebook's manual bid, you control the bid cost, meaning you can define a maximum bid value that it places per auction. Basically, those are the two pillars that the Facebook auction is divided into. So responsiveness, creative responsiveness, and budget. That's which are the bids you'll be placing in the auction there. And based on that, if you have an ad with good engagement, it shows you in more auctions and cheaper auctions and you lower your CPA. For Facebook to organize this auction, it divides all its audiences into clusters, as we call them, which are groups of people within each audience. So cluster means a group of people, right? That's it. Cluster is a group of people. I mean, there's a whole weight loss market here, a big one. So there will be these small, these little clusters within the market, which are these mini groups, these subgroups within the market. And then there'll be like an ultra awesome group, man, these guys are buyers. So the price will be a bit higher. What really happens is that within a cluster, there can be good people, buyers, and unqualified people. So your auction must reach the good segment within that cluster. And the more clusters you show, the higher the chance you have to validate your creative. If you have a good creative, a good creative that could validate and scale, but it was only shown to a bad cluster, the chance of it failing to validate is high. So this is the first variable you need to beat that you need to isolate within the Facebook creative test. So for example, you're selling a plan, just like you talked about that detox diet. You are an affiliate for. You'll go onto Facebook and then you'll enter the interest weight loss or gym, fitness, or whatever. And let's say that within this cluster, there are a million people, just to make my example easier. And Facebook then divides these 1 million people into 10 clusters of 100, 000 to organize itself for the auction. If you launch an ad set just for that creative, it might land in a good cluster or it might land in a bad one. If it lands in a bad one, the chance of it validating is low. You'll lose the assertiveness of your creatives. So what exactly do we do to isolate this variable? We run the exact same creative to different audiences, meaning one creative necessarily has to run in more than one ad set. So the way you have to test, and here we get into a more technical part. Just to confirm I understood, okay? The same creative, when you say audiences in practice, could be the same interest. It'll just re-upload the set. Exactly. Duplicate and put the same ad in that set. So like, instead of having a set written there uh, like academic interest you'll have like five sets with academic interest in each one and each of them will go to a different type of cluster. Exactly, identical sets, identical. Even with specific interests or open audiences, people nowadays target more broadly than by interest. Well, the exact same ad sets, same age segmentation and geolocation, if you're utilizing geolocation, identical. Just to isolate the cluster variable. What I mean is, the way I test today is using CBO 151, which is the structure we refer to. CBO, one campaign. Five ad sets, one ad. Explain CBO to beginners. CBO is basically how Facebook distributes the budget among the ad sets. It's campaign budget optimization, meaning if you have a CBO. With 300 RIAs and five ad sets, Facebook will distribute those 300 RIAs among the five ad sets there to the ones it believes are converting best, getting more clicks, and so on. I think the acronym is campaign budget optimization, right? Which is. Yes, that's it. Campaign level budget optimization. Campaign level. Exactly. And there's CBO. There's ABO, right? Right, dude. It's the ad set budget for ad set level optimization. You're good. You drove traffic. I'm tough, man. He's the boss, folks. Don't mess with me, man. Don't mess with me, bro. Come on. I told you I was full stack, didn't I? That's right, dude. I told you I was. That's right. The ABO, in fact, distributes at the ad set level, right? So Facebook doesn't choose the best. You set 20 REAs for the ad set. It will spend those 20, whether it's good or bad, bringing results or not. And do you prefer testing with CBO? I prefer it because I have the. With CBO, I have the help of Facebook's super smart algorithm. So if it judges that ad set B can bring me more conversion and it's going to allocate more budget to that ad set, I let it work that way. So if an ad set is performing poorly, Facebook itself will stop putting budget into it, saving me money and putting it toward the good ones, you know? And how? Like, if that's true, alright, I don't know if you will be able to answer this question. But I am going to ask, why does the ABO exist then? Like, if the CBO is superior. Look, Facebook actually started with ABO. CBO is more recent. Oh, that's right. Moreover, the future of Facebook is. What Facebook has in mind for the platform for the ads manager is for the store owner, someone completely non-technical, to be able to launch and optimize an ad campaign. So anything Facebook creates that it can take out of the user's hands, the optimization, it will do. That's why the Advantage Plus campaigns have now emerged. They are even more optimized than CBO. Man, I don't know this shit. I have no idea what that is. I saw it there. There's an ad. I run from the the upsell thing my traffic manager ended up leaving the company. So I had to run a test there and this advantage thing was there. I was like, 'What the hell is this man?' I could even choose the audience, you know. There's no audience preset, this campaign has no proper setup, so basically you can't segment anything in it because Facebook wants to do everything through. So what is the trend for Facebook for the next few years? Well, all the segmentation will be done by your creative. Meaning, if you want to talk and man, and send your campaigns, deliver your campaigns to copywriters, for example, your creative, your hook, needs to talk about copywriting. And then Facebook's own machine learning will direct these ads to the right people. So you won't be able to segment anymore. Age, I believe, will remain. But interest audiences will probably die out. And this all also has to do with the iOS 14 update, right? Because Facebook no longer has access to the audience profile. That's within those interests due to third-party cookies, you know? So Facebook is adapting, creating this type of campaign where it's, it fully uses its artificial intelligence. You know? And the Advantage Plus campaigns are optimized by AI. It's a different algorithm from CBO and ABO. And I believe that the future of Facebook will be the campaigns you know so people have less and less user interference there, but you don't think it's current yet. Nowadays, you run more CBO than ABO. For example, that's why we created the structure test within the methodology. Each offer performs best in a specific structure. Some offers perform better with CBO, others with ABO, and now I've included Advantage Plus in this test to see which offer yields the most profit. Uh, is ABO still superior for some offers then? Yes. Especially in the US, we still use ABO. Oh, really? You know the reason why this happens, don't you? Man, no. I don't know why that happens. I don't know if there's a technical reason for it, and I see it varies a lot. There's a lot of seasonality depending on the time. There are times when CBO is like completely booming, giving massive ROI, then suddenly it stops. Then you do a structure test, the same offer, the same creative in ABO. It starts selling again and scales. So I see that it's often like that. You have to nail the timing of the offer. Do a structure test. By the way, here's a tip, folks. Always do a structure test on new offers, right? The ones you just validated. So do a prescale with the structure test. You should create three campaigns for each one and analyze over a seven-day period which one gave you the most profit. The one that gave the most profit is the one you'll take to scale. Then you'll set up the structure for scaling. This seems important, right? Uh, I think that, just like, a single offer price test is extremely important. So you can hit the offers scale with an optimalYes, because it gives you the peace of mind. knowing that you're scaling the offer in the most optimized structure that it could be running. So, for you to run the offer, like for it to saturate at the best possible ROI, to squeeze all the juice out of it, to extract it, to wring the offer dry. Exactly. Got it. You also have scale testing today. We'll talk about that, but nowadays you need to test scaling because some offers handle vertical scaling and some don't. So sometimes a really good offer you'll increase its budget intraday, which is what we call intraday optimization. And it will stop working. It won't sell. But what if the next day you launch a completely horizontal scale without making changes to the budget, for example? You launch 10 ad sets, and then instead of adjusting the budget, you just pause the ones that have hit your CPA limit. And you let the good performers run without increasing anything. I know it gives you an itch. Like, you see a roast of four in a campaign, you'll want to increase the budget, but you don't touch it. Because when you do this vertical scale test and it doesn't perform, it's usually an offer that won't withstand that type of scaling. So then you'll scale everything horizontally. And that's where you'll need lateralization, right? Both in terms of the number of campaigns and ad accounts. Right. We'll talk about it, right? Am I rushing? Uh, no. Just relax, man. But getting back, okay? So the first thing I'm going to do, I'll test my creative. You said there are two important things. Creative responsiveness, basically the size of the, uh. How much Facebook likes this creative, which will probably be a sum like of likes of engagement about sharing. It's the total sum of people's feedback, whether they're. And then there's the budget part, which you said is also very important. Great. I already understood that. So, you said you like to test nowadays, right? With this CBO structure, which is a campaign with a budget already at the campaign level, and then you said you test with five ad sets that will deliver to audiences, uh, that will have the same audience set, but even by- setting the same audience, it will still deliver to different clusters within those audiences. And that's often why, you know, it's happened to me many times, right? 10 ad sets each with a different CPA, but it's the same audience, right? Like what the hell is this exact same interest you targeted open audience and all, but it still gives a different result. That's it. I get it. So we've covered variable one of the creative test, the audience segment. But did we really cover that though? There isn't a possibility. Well, a possibility, yes. But, uh, in your experience, if I put five sets there, I already kind of zero out the clusters. Not zero, but I show a sufficient number of clusters there that kind of says, 'Oh, I'll probably find a good cluster,' you know? Well, it's not really a certainty. But we're working with probabilities, right? So the probability of hitting a bad cluster is much higher in one set than in five, right? Once you diversify at least one of those will work. And I like CBO because it's precisely on that one that Facebook will concentrate the budget. So that's why I conduct my tests this way. And seriously, this significantly boosts the effectiveness of creatives. In fact, I even taught a class at VTurb showing exactly how to perform this test. And I always tell people: 'Look, if you've recently tested a creative and it showed low assertiveness and you're conducting your test differently from what I'm explaining here, then retest those creatives using CBO because I'm absolutely certain they will validate.' And honestly, it's a guaranteed success. You know, people take 10 creatives that didn't validate, retest them this way in CBO 151. It's bizarre how some of those 10 creatives that hadn't validated, they validate in this new test, you know? Well, in that case, if I'm going to test 10 creatives, that's 10 CBO. Exactly. 10 CBO with 50 ad sets. That's how it's going to be. Yeah. But then it's five per campaign. Yes. That comes out to 50 ad sets. Exactly. I got it, dude. So folks, people always have this question. So I'll Uh, within these five ad sets, it's the same creative. Okay. So for example, creative one goes into all five sets. They are not different creatives. Um, Got it. Excellent. Yes, excellent. With this, we'll try to present it to the greatest number of clusters we possibly can, right? So that we can then, well, ultimately, receive some kind of feedback to understand what's going on. Man. You realize that my intuition tells me that actually, my intuition and logic also that the more quality the offer has, the more accurate these groups will be. So, if the offer is bad, maybe you do this and then Facebook found those specific clusters. Like, say, a weight loss offer, and located that group with those women and he found that audience of women who were sitting in front of their computers crying with a credit card in hand because they were overweight. She sees your offer, oh my god, and she buys it. So it's easy to convert. However, there will be other clusters there with less qualified people and a good offer. It will still convert those guys. So a good offer will have greater assertiveness in the clusters, right? In the clusters, exactly that. Can we really predict how much an offer or, rather, a campaign will actually scale based on the sheer number of ad sets that validate in this creative test? Man, how much it will scale. No. But you already have an anticipation there that probably that offer will leave the pre-scale. It will gain scaling traction. Now, how much it will scale, I think it's more linked to the ROAS of the pre-scale. Scale so, for example, you found the creatives validated them, regardless of how many sets you launched it for pre-scaling, and that creative there maintained its, I mean, with a rose of 2. 53, with more budget allocated, that offer will probably scale to a six-figure return. And if you get variations of that creative right, a seven-figure return. I think it's more connected to the rows that the offer delivers in pre-scale than the actual number of ad sets that validate during the test. Okay, after you've done that, is the next step the prescale, or is there still more? Right. There's another creative test variation, right? Two more, actually. The second variation is the budget. And it's precisely for this very reason that we always place just one creative within each ad set. The Facebook algorithm, if you put more than one ad, more than one creative within the ad set, man, regardless if it's two creatives or 10, one of them or several of them will always end up not receiving budget. Why? The Facebook algorithm is programmed to allocate the budget to whatever is performing best. However, this outcome isn't always about conversion. It's possible you created a very clickbait ad and then 80% of the clicks are going to that specific ad. But that particular ad isn't necessarily the one that converts the most. And let's just imagine you've put a hundred Brazilian Reyes into an ad set or CBO to test it out. And man, Facebook will direct eight of those hundred reais to that creative that's getting more clicks. But it might be that the one receiving 20 is actually generating more conversions for you. Maybe a longer creative generates fewer clicks, a lower CTR. But for Facebook, the algorithm isn't smart enough at the start of the test to differentiate this. For example, all right, this creative here is receiving fewer clicks, but it's generating a much more qualified audience. I'll direct more budget towards it. No, that's not what it actually does. He'll say, 'Oh, okay, this one is receiving more clicks, so it's on this one that I'll put the budget.' So to avoid this problem, you isolate the creative within the ad set and only use one creative. Then all the budget you have will be tested on that creative, because the creative that receives less budget will influence your test. That one could be a creative that would be validated, but it ends up not being validated because it's receiving a lot less budget than the others. So we separate everything by campaign and ad set. Never add the same creative within the five ad sets or the three, right? I test a lot of CBO 131 as well, 131 and 151. And the entire budget to spend on that single creative, that's why we set up if you have 10 creatives to test, you set up 10 CBO. So you're also isolating the creative variable with that. And then nowadays there's a third. A third variable. which is market seasonality. How do we go about isolating this variable? The creative really needs to be running for a minimum of three days. Every single offer nowadays will have at least one bad sales day or even more than one. offers that always lose money on Mondays and offers that always lose money on Thursdays. So, if you launch a creative test and run it only on Monday for example, which is a bad day for that offer this will influence your test and you'll fail to validate creatives that would have validated on subsequent days. So you test for a time window of at least three days to eliminate them. And then you've eliminated all possible variables from your test. Right. And man, if you didn't come out with a validated creative with these three variables being taken into account, it's because you probably have an. Offer problem because you've already isolated every possible traffic variable within the creative test by doing this. So let me see if I got it. I'll summarize. Correct me if I'm wrong. Okay, dude. All right, I'm going to test creatives. Two important things: engagement creatives and the budget that I'll allocate. Perfect. Then I'll consider. By the way, there's this this other variable which is seasonality, right? Exactly. Perfect. So then I'm going to create a CBO. For each creative, each one will have its own CBO. And within that CBO, going to have five to three ad sets um, exactly each set with the same creative. So, if I have 10 creatives, there will be 10 CBOs, one for each creative. Uh-huh, and so with that approach, I guarantee I'll have a whole lot of classes there that I'll get right because I'll have more ad sets in each CBO and then also I'm going to let that run for approximately three days because I want to overcome this seasonality. I don't want my creative to be tested on a really bad day. Seriously, today is a national holiday. Am I going to test the creative on a holiday? People are at the beach, you know? People aren't in a buying mood. Yes, that's right. I understand. That's really great. So, what kind of budget, what kind of actual money are you putting into this CBO? Look, I have the following policy. On Facebook, you need to, you have to spend money to make money, right? So you need to spend to sell. You won't be able to sell a product where you receive, let's say, in affiliate marketing in the United States, for example, $150 in commission. That, that today is almost 900 Ries. You're not going to get a 900 Ries commission spending 10 on the creative test. Facebook will just laugh in your face. So it might just happen it is something that could happen but but not the rule in 2014 2015, perhaps it might have happened but nowadays it's much more difficult, but then you need to allocate a budget that's compatible with the commission you're receiving or the value of your property's sale. So, if it's an info product priced at 147 Ries or 197, I, these days, since I have more cash flow, I prefer to aim for at least one ticket, which means one commission. So, for each creative asset, the value would be one commission, like 900 Ries in the United States. Thank you. But if you have less cash, use 50% of that budget. It still works well. If the creative is good, you'll validate it with half the spend. And so That's the budget, and it's split across three days. So, if my commission is 100 Rees, for example, and I want to spend the amount of one commission, am I going to spend 33 Rees per day for three days on each CBO, right? No. In this particular case, I like to set this specific amount because to get into a really good auction, you truly need a decent budget. So I set this amount to spend each and every day. Per day. But in the creative test, you can already do daily optimization. So. I'll give an affiliate example to make it easier, okay? Let's say it's an affiliate who gets paid in CPA, right? Which is a fixed commission and he gets $150. And then let's say that $150 is like 900 raised. Since you only spend on traffic, you know how to set an ideal CPA. Generally, we consider a ROAS of 1. 8 or 2. In other words, a good creative needs to sell up to 50% of that budget amount. That is, if you have a 900 res commission and you want a ROAS 2, that creative needs to generate a sale within 450 Ries of spend. If it spent those 450 and didn't sell, you can pause that creative for the day and resume running it the next day. In other words, by the end of the three days, you always end up with the same amount or very close to the amount that you would have spent if you had simply divided that budget across the three days. Maybe you'll spend a little more, a little less, but this daily optimization, done already during the creative test, saves you a lot of budget because you aren't constantly burning money on a creative that, well. And then, obviously, by also looking at the secondary metrics, you'll see if the CPC is outside your niche. You'll see if the CPM is much higher than normal, and then you'll keep an eye out to prevent money from burning up. Got it? I understand. That's basically it. Alright, um, look, I've got here, like, one, two, three, I have three questions I need to ask you about this, okay? Uh. First of all, okay? Just going back a bit, I want to talk about the metrics. I want to talk about Facebook's algorithm. And I also want to talk about reducing costs during the tests, okay? But going back, right at the very beginning of our test, the first thing we're going to do is actually have the creative, right? Yes. And look, I know you're not a copywriter. But I know you understand copy, and man, the traffic manager, since we're talking about the full stack, he somewhat understands creatives. We're talking about that part of, well, understanding what's happening in the market to find references so you can model things for your niche. Sometimes there's something scaling up really well in the weight loss niche that you can take and model for relationships. I did this a lot not just nowadays, but with really old copies too. There was a headline that went like this: 'Excuse me. Why does this doctor say I haven't drunk water in 20 years? I modeled that as: 'Excuse me. Why does this dentist say I haven't used toothpaste in 20 years for a teeth whitening product, you know?' Uh-huh. So this is something that's really interesting to do. And so my question is, man, what do you think the MVP really is? Like just the basics without going too deep. Okay. Uh-huh. Um, but for these people, you know the basics. Hey, I'm a traffic manager, and I really want to understand creatives. Man, how to actually create them? How can they manage to produce really good Even if they're not particularly strong copywriters, how exactly does that whole process work? Man, like we said, I think the main thing is market intelligence. It's knowing what's truly working. So for someone to be good at creative, they need to spy. They need to be a kind of an ad library, deep diver, they're researching keywords for the niche they want to. And seeing everything that's performing well in terms of editing, in terms of copy, for example, in terms of format. So nowadays, the format matters a lot. What's the format for those who don't know? Well, the format is basically how you're going to convey that sales message, right? So it could be a UGC format, which is that more native content, right? That's right. It could be a news format. It could be a podcast format. So then there are some formats work better, better suited for certain niches, right? So nowadays, for example, in the ED niche, for instance, UGC really works well. It's what I see running the most. The React format also, which is a format I see performing extremely well, is like what these bloggers do. A video plays in the background, that's the creative, and then he reacts like, 'Oh guys, look what's going to happen here now, and so on.' This is quite native, isn't it? It's extremely effective. Nowadays, I'm observing a very strong trend where what's truly setting the standard for effective creatives and paid traffic, specifically in direct response, is largely influenced by what originates from organic content. So I'm seeing a lot of people bringing trends from platforms like TikTok directly into the creative assets for their direct response offers. So I think that UGC really came from that, you know, people take what's gone viral on TikTok, that specific format, and then they bring it to run in paid traffic. And it generally works out well because content consumption, you know, is practically the same thing. So the more organic you can manage to make it, I believe it will perform. Yes, it will perform better. Nice. So if the person knows how to spy and can find these good ads, they'll already have a very clear direction on what they need to do to get it right. And nowadays, I believe that the 80-20 principle for a creative is a really effective hook. So the traffic manager who truly understands and can analyze exactly why that specific hook from a scale creative performed so well, and then successfully replicate that insight into their advertisements, they won't need to be an absolute master of copywriting to produce an ad that genuinely converts. This is of course, provided you have a good offer and crucially a validated offer. But I think, man, if you've got the hook and format strategy down, you've practically got the 80-20 chance to nail a creative. Yeah, good point. Man, that was actually my second question, you know, because if we use this CBO format with one creative, we're going to end up with a Five ad sets right one creative in each one, but I don't know about you. Okay, but when I was running traffic every time I launched a creative it wasn't released alone. That creative launched with three extra hooks, three different starting points. Sometimes, you know, a really minor silly variation. Man, in a creative, back in my day, it was like, in a creative concept, we'd look at the camera here, and a headline would appear right on top of the camera, you know, of the video. That's right. So there was someone talking and the overlay said how to reduce wrinkles. Followed by three tips to that headline was key. It's what really stopped people in their tracks. That was a pattern for a long time, right? That headline. A lot. A play a lot with that until recently, man. Well, anyway. So like, do you think this is still worth doing today? Uh, and in that case, we'd have a CBO. For each creative variation. Or then, you know, a CBO. Instead of just one creative, we'd put two, which is like the same creative, but with different hooks. Man, this question is really, really good, dude. This question is excellent because it made me think about something we've been doing recently. So what is it that we've been doing? Uh, For every creative that we launch, we are now releasing it with three distinct hooks, whether it's a change in the angle of the copy itself or in the editing. Because if we operate on the principle that all Facebook segmentation will be done based on the creatives, each hook you create will reach a different audience. And that hook, it can reach a buying audience as well as a non-buying audience. So it's crazy because if you consider that a creative performs really well with one specific hook but with another hook even with the exact same copy in the body of that creative it doesn't perform so we start to think that the hook is like not 80-20 but maybe the 90-10 of the creative. Sure. So what have we been doing? We create these three hook variations for each creative. And since it's the same body, and this happens just like I said, in this case, we put all the variations inside the same CBO. But I do this because I consider that creative to be the same. The same creative. That's right. But if you want to isolate everything, it's not wrong. Actually, it's even more effective. But it does require capital, you know? Yeah, besides the effort, it requires a lot of money, right? Yeah, that would be an expensive test, man. Because, man, 10 creatives there, that would become 30, you know? For sure. So it's kind of bizarre and it's a lot of money, but that would be the ideal world. Then you'd isolate everything. Yes. But it's possible to do it this way. Put everything in the same group and let Facebook itself distribute it. Yeah, man, that's how I did it. I'd set it up and just say, 'Okay, it's in God's hands now.' If it made sales, great. If not, it is what it is. And man, we're basically trusting Facebook, you know, to deliver better results there and so on with CBO. Uh huh. Well, the thing is, we know that Facebook is very intelligent, but after this iOS 14 update, for those who aren't aware, you know? Apple, a while back, they implemented a policy where they basically cut off the sending of user data to all those traffic platforms. So, if you own an iPhone, for example, Facebook no longer knows whether you've made a purchase or not because they're simply not sending that information anymore. You know, it's a whole thing. I can't really explain all the technical details perfectly, but that's essentially what happened. Something messed up over there. The pixel got, got kind of blind. So, like, Like Facebook isn't, uh, not very reliable anymore. You know, actually not even back in my day, man, when this wasn't even a thing, it's pixel never tracked correctly. You know, that's why there's a whole market for tracking. Such that's why all this exists, because these companies profit from Facebook's inefficiency, if Facebook were good, if it tracked correctly. There would be no need for any tracking at all. So I think this variable of the pixel and these kinds of things influences quite a lot, you know? So I wanted to know from you, how do you see all this? Do you think that there's a tracking setup worth implementing to make the CBO more assertive? Or do you just say, 'Ah, it's going to be inaccurate anyway, screw it, it will run, but if it gets 40% right, that's'Honestly, nowadays, I simply can't work without a tracking tool, you know? Because, like Facebook, it's gonna lose at least 60 of the conversions, so, in a creative test, where you you'll only get three or four sales for your creative to validate or not. You'd lose, if you made four sales, you'd lose three of those. So you can't trust Facebook at all in that regard. This applies both to creative testing and at scale. At scale, especially because with daily optimization, you'll need to know exactly which ad set is selling so you can increase your budget, decrease your budget, and so on. So man, this tracking part, there's absolutely no way it can be done in any other manner than with the proper tools. In fact, when I launched TDA, the use of these tools wasn't very widely known yet, right? There were only a few of them and they were extremely expensive. So people, only giant operations were already using this and we were doing everything manually. We used to put the little SRC code in the UTM, right? So we take the platform's SRC code, put it in the Facebook parameter, then in the checkout, and it would appear in the sales report. So what would we do? We take the sales report to see the name of the ad set that had made the sale. Note it down in an Excel spreadsheet. And we'd manually calculate the CPA. Certainly. So these tools came along to save our lives, man, for a traffic manager. Without them, it's impossible. But then, you see, we can't really trust Facebook to send us the correct traffic there. If we're going to implement CBO, then will the error be exactly the same across all of the ad sets? Yes. So, you just leave it wrong there. Screw it. What you'll be looking at is your tracker, or your UTM, you know, to see what's happening. That's exactly right. And ultimately, that's what you'll use to determine if the creative sold or not, right? Well, these days, man, we barely use the ad manager itself for optimization. You know, we just look at the. Tracker and the manager today basically is just to launch campaigns. What tracker do you recommend for everyone? Man, nowadays on a stronger level, I recommend Red Track. Click Magic is also good. And Utmify, man, Utmify is coming on very strong. Their tool is really good. For me, Utmify is the best. Dashboard among all of them because you can use it on your phone, pause, increase the budget on your phone. So this helps a lot in a manager's daily routine. Oh, no doubt. Red Track, it's more it is for tracking capabilities. Red Track is, man, unbelievable. But it has these kinds of features. You can tell it's a foreign platform. They don't really care much about the user experience. So, if you're going to subscribe to it, you'll need to call a programmer to set it up if the user himself can't handle the configuration. So, they really fall short in these areas. That's why, Upmify, it truly helps a lot, especially for those who are just starting out. Have you already tested that Nemu? Man, I tested Nemu, well, I think it was last year. I tested Namu. And as soon as I started testing Namu, I really liked their solution and then quickly launched Utmify. And I immediately started using Utmify. So, you tried Utmify and it fit better? Well, it had more functionality. It was easier to set up. And then I liked them better. I thought. Man, I'll use Utmify here. Stay there, right? Back then, I only operated in Brazil. Uh huh. Because nowadays in the United States, you need a more robust tracker because the pre-sale aspect is very important, right? So you need to measure the pre-sale passage. And I don't think Utmify has that function. At least I don't know. Hey, Marcio, here's a tip for you, man. It's true, man. If you do that, you're going to come on, man. You're going to dominate the market, man. Today. Just to give you an idea, in one of our offers in the United States, we are using Utmify and ClickMagic. I use ClickMagic only to track the pre-lander's journey, and I handle everything else using Utmify. Oh my God, that's crazy. So I use both because, man, I really like that dashboard from Utmify for mobile use, you know? So cool. That's so real. It's funny, right, man? Uh, there are tracking tools out there, okay? These are much more expensive tools, like significantly more, uh, professional ones that-And I'm not speaking ill of Utmify. Not at all, okay? It's like a really good product. Uh, I mean, I've never used it. But people who do say it's great. But back in my day, man, I actually used a tool called Hyros. Have you ever heard of it? Right, yeah, yeah. It's a foreign platform, quite. Uh, I've never used it, you know? I think it's even more expensive than Red Track, if I'm not mistaken. A hell of a lot. We'd pay, if I'm not mistaken, I think it was $10, 000 or $15, 000 a month. It was some bizarre stuff. Right, it was expensive. Uh, Lucas will know. Okay, Lucas is just like that. Folks, he has a podcast with him. It's appearing on your screen a YouTube podcast after this is over. Go watch it. But heroes, what the deal? Right, just look at how copy grabs people. Huh, their ad copy was as follows. Man, we've got tracking, but not common tracking. Facebook is garbage. So we're going to take your conversion data and directly feed it into Facebook's AI to optimize the campaign even more effectively. Man, that copy back then was wild, right? Damn it. Man, he paid $15, 000. I said, Dude. This is it, man. That's it. I need to optimize. Just feed that. Hey, has that ever worked for you? Have you ever like seen anything about this? Have you tested it? Do you know if it worked for you? Think it worked for me, okay? At least Hyros, right? Lucas, if I'm wrong, comment below. But as far as I recall, man, it was just a mess, you know? Like, we paid a hell of a lot because of the copy. The strength of the copy, you know? Look, honestly, nowadays, most of the tools out there have this feature, right? Upmify itself actually does this. Oh, really? You put a code. I think it's JS. I don't understand any of this, but it's a JS code you put on your page. And so this code, it captures the UTM, right? And sends it to Facebook in that specific UTM parameter. So Facebook knows. But why don't I believe it? I might be talking the biggest load of nonsense in the world here because I'm somewhat of a novice when it comes to tracking issues. I truly don't believe that this actually improves campaign performance. Why? What is it that most of these tools actually do? It captures the conversion here for Facebook from its own page, links it to the checkout, and notifies Facebook that, hey, a conversion happened in this ad set. Understood? So Facebook knows and attributes that conversion to ad set A, for example. Therefore, Facebook is already aware that a conversion originated from that specific ad set. But in the funnel model we're running, since the user doesn't have to fill out any info on the landing page, Facebook still doesn't gain access to the buyer's customer profile. It only knows there was a conversion, that is, it knows a purchase occurred in ad set A, but it doesn't know it was Ms. Maria, 63 years old, who lives in some unknown location. Therefore, it cannot build this buyer-customer profile based on the conversions that the tracking tools send. So this is useful for guiding your decisions because then you can even trust the ad manager since the tracker is attributing the data to the manager. So Facebook is indeed tracking. The correct conversion quantity. But the actual quality of that conversion, in my opinion, doesn't really change, even though the pixel score might sometimes improve there and so on. Because if you aren't using anything at all today, the standard score of the that score is specifically for conversion attribution. And there are various different points within the pixel itself. So the profile, everything is based on data hashing. And the score ranges from 0 to 10. In the standard, just using Facebook's API at checkout you'll get i don't know six and a half seven with a tracker, sometimes it even improves to nine nine and a half, and many trackers market themselves based on this improvement of the pixel. But I don't feel this improvement in the day-to-day traffic and in the conversion of that offer, you know? Because I believe that Facebook still doesn't have access to this customer's data. To build that buyer profile and then say, 'No, it's precisely this type of person here that I need to show these advertisements to, which will convert more effectively, which is exactly what Facebook used to do before, right? Facebook had Indeed, it is. Look. Me too, folks, okay? I'm not a traffic manager, but in my experience, I don't think it added value either. If it had, I think I would know. I think people would say, 'Man, this is giving great results.' You know it's because it's such an objective thing that, if it actually produced results, you'd plug it in and the very next day your campaign would already feel better, both in ad delivery and in conversion. And I don't feel that's what happens. You know. And obviously, I'm not speaking ill of any tool here, for heaven's sake. I just think it's a matter of Facebook not being able to identify the buyer profile of the one that generated that conversion. Yes. And I'm already, folks, I'm really talking bad, okay? That it's all a scam. No, I'm just kidding, guys. Man, that's great. Alright, so, uh, two more questions, okay? So we can move to the pre-scaling phase later on. We are testing things out there, you see. Without a doubt, we want to find you know a creative that Wow has a good CPA so we can put it into pre-scale and eventually scale it up and put money in our pockets. That's exactly what we are doing. This is the problem that we are looking to solve here. And for that, we're going to analyze the CPA, cost per action, right? Yeah, or cost per acquisition, you know, how much we spent to make a sale. We also have the secondary metrics as well. CTR, CPM, and all that crap. Yes. Man, how do you even analyze these secondary metrics? What exactly is their purpose? Are they truly useful or do we just look at CPA and screw everything else? Man, these metrics over there. They weren't that useful until, I'm going to do a little plug right now, okay? Go ahead. Until VTurb launches this traffic origin feature that you're able to see. Take that, you hear me? Go on and suck it, society. Dude, you know. V-Turb is like a mom, man. Because being able to see the retention for every single creative. Dude, that's insane because you're able to, you stop looking at an isolated metric, a secondary isolated metric, and you can actually see the retention. of that creative. In other words, how many people that creative is bringing to your pitch. So for example, how I do my creative testing today in the United States. And when people, uh, When I say you can test as an affiliate in the United States, spending $3, 000, people get mad at me. They say, 'Dude, are you crazy?' Everyone says advertising in the United States is the champions league of direct response that it costs a ton of money. I say, 'Dude, there are some things you can do with traffic that minimize this expense.' One of those things is looking at these secondary metrics, but for that, you need to know your niches' pattern. So man, join a group in research who you're going to target weight loss, for example. Research who's running ads, see how much people are paying for CPC, who's scaling, and ask, 'Hey, what's your CPM? What's your CPC?' Because if you launch a creative there, you'll see it's way off. And then you go to VTurb to the traffic source and pull that specific creative. If, compared to others, it already has a much lower retention and no initiate checkout, for example, which is a secondary metric, man, you can just kill that creative without a shadow of a doubt. It's going to be a bad creative. And I've already run several tests since this feature launched. And the creative with the lowest retention on VTurb without an initiate checkout on Facebook. Man, that creative. Creative rarely validates. I've already burned money testing this, like letting that bad creative run for three, four, five days spending, and it didn't generate sales. To see if he turns there, right? Exactly. Generates anything. So we really have to make the most of these, these features, you know, these tools. And that helps a lot because you make a more as more assertive decision, right? So man, you went through this whole process that I outlined, the three stages of the creative test. You looked at these secondary metrics, meaning you isolated the audience segment variable, budget variable, market seasonality variable. So you looked at VTurb, saw the creative's retention wasn't good. It didn't generate any initiate checkouts. Look, this creative is bad. You can just kill it. No need to keep spending your budget on it. So what happens next? And this VTurb feature, it's very good because in this case, you wouldn't even need to let it run for three days. If halfway through the second day, the metrics remained very bad and you saw its retention was low, man, just kill this creative and move on to another. And reuse this budget on a creative that's working or to test a new one. That's really good. Yeah. This allows for a significant reduction of the budget in creative testing. Well, man, my next question was, was exactly that, you know?' Because the first time someone told me this, they were like, 'Hey, Joao, I'm using that thing, man.' I'm saving so much money on tests. And I said, 'Yeah, but how?' The person who told me this, you know, was Zay. Zay Aritmaya. arithmetic arithmetic z arithmetic best math guy zay is a market number one he never misses a calculation okay not a single sum he's a dinosaur of direct response he is the enemy of of Zay Geometric. This guy here is sneaky, you know? It's true, man. I'm calling Zay for the podcast. He won't come, dude. He didn't come? He won't respond, bro. Zay's a jerk, man. Zay responds on WhatsApp, man. Man, I call, I've called him three times. He was talking nonsense. But Zay's a cattle rancher, right? So I guess he's super busy on the farm. Awesome, man. But then, in terms of CPC, CPM, that's not important at the beginning. You just let it run and that's all. If that creative is outside the niche standard, right? And on top of that, it has poor retention in the VSL. And to see that, folks, in VTurb will be that analytics, right? That analytics will have traffic source there. You can measure retention based on the UTMS. So, you put it in the creative, don't know what UTM is? My man, go study, okay? Google it, figure it out. Or talk to VTurb support, they have an article. But then you can see this creative had high retention. This one had low retention. If a creative has low retention and the secondary metric is bad, just kill it. Yeah, kill it. Okay. Is there enough? Key criterion. What's the main one, right? So like, man, this ad creative, it's just really, really bad. What can I just immediately rule out like that? Is it this one about user retention or is there another one you typically use? Honestly, it's a very secondary metric. I'm even afraid to talk about it and have people start analyzing it. But generally, this is based on my own perception. What did I do? I conducted a study once. Since I had access to many offers, I compiled a spreadsheet of all the creators. That scaled to multiple six figures, and even one creative that had sold $1. 5 million, a single creative and its variations. And I arrived at a pattern of metrics for the creatives that truly scale, not just those that validate, but those that scale. And what did I notice? The creative that gains traction for scaling usually makes its first sale spending up to 40% of its CPA, or its front-end ticket price. To make it easier for people to understand, so for example, if your front-end ticket is 200 Reis, the creative that will scale, well, its first sale will happen spending up to 40% of that value. 80 Reis. That's right. And then sales start to come in, then you optimize it, and it begins to decrease this CPA. Generally, this creative will scale very probably. But to discard the creative, you know, so we can save money on the tests. Right. So, and in this case, one of the standard metrics that I identified, I analyzed creatives from both the United States and creatives from Brazil, was the CTR. Creatives with a very low click-through rate, they rarely manage to gain significant traction for scaling. And why is that? Facebook operates in such a way that when you launch a brand new creative, its click-through rate tends to be cons- higher at first. Then it gradually starts to decline as the days go by. And CTR, for those who might not know, is the click-through rate of that particular creative in relation to all the people who are viewing that specific ad. In Brazil, a creative, I let it run for at least two days. If I don't get any sales in those two days, I analyze the CTR. A CTR below 3. 5% in Brazil? Man, I'll probably just kill that creative. Unless it's bringing me a significant number of checkouts, and I don't have an offer that's been fully validated yet. If it's an offer I'm already running, one that I know is validated, and I'm just testing the creative. If it's in Brazil, below 3. 5% CTR after two days running without any sales, I immediately kill that creative. So in my opinion, CTR is an extremely important metric because if a creative is already showing a very, very low CTR right from the start, then man, you're simply not capturing your audience's attention. You got the hook wrong, which is the 80-20 for creatives nowadays. So the chance of that creative validating is extremely low. In that case, if it's generating sales, you probably missed the hook, but you nailed the body, right? You got the creative's body, right? So it's worth it to test more hooks on this, on this creative, to take advantage of that body there to its fullest potential. So, uh, answering your question, I would look at CTR on a creative that didn't sell. In the United States, since there are many people running ads there, the CTR is generally higher, naturally higher. If you take the same creative, run it in Brazil, run it in the United States, the United States has a higher CTR. I don't know why. I don't know if the audience is more qualified, clicks more on the ads. But I see, man, ads, for example, I've seen creatives running with 47% CTR. Absurd. Damn it, man. 50% of the people Facebook shows the ad. To click on the ad. That's bizarre. I've never seen this. In Brazil, this doesn't happen, even in EDNiche. Now, I've already had 20% scaled in Brazil. Really, really high, man. 20% is high in Brazil. Damn, the US is surreal. In the United States, a 12%, 8%, or even 12% CTR is considered normal because people tend to click more there. So in the United States, if you're running an ad creative for two days without a single sale and the CTR is below 5% or 6%, that would also be a reason to kill it. But, you know, never look at this metric in isolation because secondary metrics, you can't rely on them, especially when sales are already happening, right? You'll look at your CPA. Now, if it didn't sell, you look at CTR. Man, the CTR is too low. Go to VTurb and check the traffic source. See how the retention is. If the retention is lower than the others, or if it's showing poor retention, then man, just kill this creative. It probably won't succeed. And I'm not saying that these metrics are inversely proportional because there are other variables involved, you know? A high CTR creative doesn't necessarily result in a cheap CPC, even though the click volume is higher. Facebook looks at other variables that I don't know, but it's not inversely proportional. And then you also look at your CPC, right? If the CPC is too expensive and it's not converting, then you might have the chance that you messed up the hook. That's pretty high. So I wouldn't insist on that creative. Got it. Yeah, I remember Lucas telling me this, man, that if the creative has a low CTR, it sells, but with a low CTR, alright. It might be that it operates well at a small scale, but it won't scale. In other words, it can't handle the scale, you know? Yeah, because the CTR tends to drop even further on the scale, since you'll be showing it to more people, right? So the tendency is for it to fall. But if it's sold, you have a great world there because then you just need to test the hook variation and you'll probably manage to hit a champion creative. That's true. Yeah, it totally makes sense. But man, that's absolutely wonderful. So we've successfully completed our creative testing process, alright? Certainly. So, what's going to happen now? Let's say we got a result from that. Okay, let's say 20% of the creatives, for example. I tested 10 creatives, 2 of them. CPA got hit. Now what? Dude, so that's great. You found your winning champion creatives like that. Now you're gonna By the way, what is an acceptable rate? Okay, just to understand. Like, validation. Out of 10, how many theoretically validate? Oh man, this is really difficult, you know? Because it really depends on the offer. Some offers have a high creative validation success rate. How high is that success rate? How much is that? Like 40, 50? High, 40 to 50%. Fuck, it's so high. It's high, it's high. But not necessarily this is an offer that will scale a lot because, in the pre-scale phase, it might not gain traction unless it's an offer that's already been validated, right? If it doesn't gain traction, it means the creative couldn't handle the budget. Now, if it's a new offer, and that's why I created this method, because pre-scaling validates the offer, right? I'll even repeat this. I think I already mentioned it at the beginning, but man, I see a lot of people. Especially those who are more beginners, you know. Damn, I validated a creative with a six rows. I'm rich. I crushed it. Now the guy will launch the pre-scale and go, 'I'm running at a loss here.' It yielded nothing. This happens a lot. As I mentioned earlier, The tendency is to validate a creative based on ROAS, make a profit, but then this offer won't scale in the pre-scale phase. So it's more likely for this to happen than to launch a creative test and sell nothing. Unless the copy is really bad, like sometimes with a beginner copywriter, it might happen. But then, okay, once you've found your winning creative, it's time to push them to pre-scale to see if you'll truly validate your offer, right? Absolutely. This is considering an offer from scratch. So what is the fundamental- principle of prescaling? The fundamental principle of prescaling is budget increase. So how are you going to approach your prescaling? I like to increase the budget, and this is how I validated my own pre-scaling, by tripling the budget I used for creative testing in each of the campaigns. And this is also the moment to start horizontally scaling the campaign. So let's assume. We'll use a creative as an example to make it easier. So you tested 10 creatives and validated a really strong one. Let's say you got a four-row in that creative test. You're going to put it into pre-scaling. You're going to create five CBO. Tripling the budget for each of these CBOs compared to what you used for the creative test. So let's say you're running an info product for 200 rays. You tested the creative with 200 rays. Each of these five CBO will have 600 rays of budget in the pre-scale. That campaign, the one I used and validated, it's dead. I'll pause it. I'll leave it running there. I like to use it in the pre-scale. So you just increase her budget and then just double it? Yes, exactly. Because then, since it already has conversion data. Theoretically, it's a more optimized campaign, so there's simply no reason not to use it. If you're going to use five campaigns, you duplicate four of them using the one that already came from the test, the one that was already working. And then you'll start running with a budget of around 600 REs in each CBO. Three times. Is that three times the validation budget? Yes, exactly. Because you're driving a much higher volume of views on that creative, on that offer. And here you can see we're talking about offer validation and we did all the. creative testing without even glancing at the offer metrics. So up until now, I haven't discussed lead retention, play rate, or anything like that because the budget is very small. There are likely very few views on the VSL for you to actually make a concrete decision regarding the funnel or the copy itself. So, from the moment that you increase the budget in the pre-scale phase, you'll drive a higher volume of views on that VSL, allowing you to make more informed decisions because you'll have a larger volume of views and data. So here you are, in fact, testing your offer. And it's here that we'll start looking at the funnel metrics, properly speaking. The metrics of the offer, the copy, and so on. The pre-scale phase must run for at least five days. And here you can start, or rather you've already done the daily optimization during the creative test, right? Because you paused and then reactivated the campaigns that hit the CPA. In this pre-scale phase, you'll also be doing the very same thing. If your ideal CPA is hit without a sale, you pause the campaign and turn it back on the next day. And you do that for at least five days. These five days aren't a hard rule. Yeah, if you validate very strongly, like on the first or second day of pre-scale, you've, I don't know, increased the budget. And the offer is still delivering a ROAS of 2. 5 or 3. Man, you can already send that to scale, okay? You don't need to run it for five days. But if it's that kind of struggling thing, kind of mashing the mud and all, leave it for five. Mashing the mud? Mashing the mud, yeah. I hadn't heard that one. That's from the countryside of Sao Paulo. Mashing the mud? So you learned another one today. And mashing the mud now. Yeah, mashing the mud is like, you don't get anywhere, the offer makes a profit one day and a loss the next. So leave it running for that period to isolate that variable of market seasonality too, which also affects scaling. And then here, starting on the second or third day, you'll actually start to look at your VSL metrics because you already have validated creatives. And then you can start focusing on the offer. And that's where you'll see, how is my lead retention? How is my play rate? How is the connect rate? That is, how is my page open rate? Is it above 80% relative to the people who click? Uh-huh. Then you'll look at all the funnel metrics to be like, 'All right, I'm losing money, man.' Let's see where the bottleneck is. So usually the bottleneck is either the connect rate, right? People are clicking on your ad. But the page takes too long to load, so they're leaving. Or it's your very low play rate. And here, in the case of an offer that's just breaking even, or one day it's profitable, and the next it's losing money, a play rate below 70% is usually a bottleneck. Nowadays, it's difficult to get a high play rate. It's been a long time since I've seen a play rate like 80% or more than that, you know. Lead retention: see if your lead is retaining more than 60 or 70 percent in that first minute so you're not seeing a huge drop off on the graph and then retention all the way to the pitch. Because, you know, retention up to the pitch, it really, it varies significantly from one niche to another, right? So sometimes you're having a retention. This happens a lot with ED offers, for example. Retention historically by default is low, but the conversion is very high. So, like everyone who goes to checkout buys, you know, 80%. So in this case, low retention up to the pitch isn't necessarily a problem. That won't stop you from scaling. If you're converting with few people, the more people you can get to the pitch, the better. This will probably, it will drop a bit, but man, you'll be able to scale more. So optimizing your lead gen if it's converting less and checkout conversion. These are the main metrics that I start looking at during the pre-scale. And how do you define, uh, actually, let me just see if I've understood this, okay? So, I can give a summary here for everyone. Man, I went there, put the creative up. Then I ran it in the creative testing phase and the creative got a good ROAS, like a ROAS of two and a half. Great. So I'm going to take that one. This and I'm gonna launch more ad sets you mentioned five ad sets, right? I work with five sets, each with three times the budget. So if in the creative, my ad set had 100 REAs, now I'm going to launch 5 ad sets, each with 3 times 100 REAs, which is 300 REAs. Got it? And then you'll let that run for 5 days to see what's happening. During this five-day period, then you're going to actually we also need to analyze the funnel, right? Like you mentioned, analyze the VSL checkout conversion and all that, and retention. Which I'm going to ask you about as well, uh, because I really need to know what to do in this specific situation, right? Absolutely. But uh, before all that, okay, what exactly should I do with the creative? Do I really just let it run for these five days, even if it's not selling, or uh I'm not sure. Is there something else I should do beforehand? For example, that process of checking the creative's retention can that still be applied here, or was it already validated in that aspect previously? Yeah, man, you know, I tend to rely on my creative test because otherwise you'll just keep doing what I call the infinite test, right? You'll constantly be monitoring the creative metrics. And I think you need to have gone past the creative testing phase. Did it truly validate after all those steps were completed? So you isolated the club, the budget, the market seasonality, and the creative still validated? Wow, it came out of the three-day creative test with a 2. 5 ROAS. Man, this creative is validated. So you trust the stage of your test and then you start to look at other stages to be able to continue and complete the validation, because otherwise you'll remain in that infinite creative testing loop. But if this creative has been validated and in the pre-scale phase, it's not generating profit. Then the likelihood of you having an offer problem is quite high. Your problem is probably with the offer itself. Because it can't handle this slightly less qualified audience. since you're creative having a larger budget is being shown to more people right so these are less qualified audiences you know the more you show it to more people the less qualified the audience becomes comes exactly and the offer has no selling power exactly just to make it very clear this is for when you're validating a brand new offer that you've never run before if you already have a validated offer that's scaling with other creatives and this happens, for example, the creative went to prescale and couldn't handle the budget, then the problem is probably with the creative, not the offer. That's why it's hard nowadays to hit on a creative that scales well like that. And people really have to, they have to test a large volume of creatives because it's hard for a creative to actually take off and scale. In this specific case, where you already have an offer scaling, pre-scaling stops serving to validate the offer and continues to be for validating the creative. In other words, it's kind of a continuation of the creative testing process when you already have a validated offer. For a new offer, though, in this second stage, you already need to start looking at your offer metrics. Got it. Man, but you see we're at a bit of an impasse here in the pre-scale because and I'm sure you know that the people watching at home must have this exact same doubt. And folks, I'm going to ask exactly what you want to know, okay? Because I already know. I just know that everyone's going to ask this. It's like, man, if I'm in pre-scale, Uh-huh. So let's say I have a 2. 5 ROAS. Then I took that creative, set it up with three times the budget, started running it, and it didn't sell, okay? It put me in the red. In the pre-scale? In the pre-scale. Right. How am I going to know if the problem is the creative, which isn't holding up in pre-scale, or if the problem is the offer and it's just not validated? In that case, you need more validated creatives before you can really say the problem is with the offer. If I have a lot of validated creatives and none of them work for the offer, Oh, man. You're further decreasing the chance of it being a creative problem. It's all about probability. In fact, it makes sense. Do you have an idea of how many? Validated Creatives It would take to scrap an offer. For example, ah, I have three creatives that worked during testing but didn't work in pre-scaling. Can I say the offer's the problem just because of those three creatives? Man, I'd say about five creatives with different angles. Validated, that don't gain traction at scale, I think that's a good number. Because with different angles, you're hitting distinct audiences, and even so, you're not able to scale. So your bottleneck is probably in the offer. Yeah, that really makes sense, doesn't it? Let me quickly write this down. Okay. Great. Awesome. And man uh, let's say we ran it right and we managed to get a bit of a roy there. So the pre-scale still turned a profit if we, if during validation we were at, you know, a row us of 2. 5 or 3. Right and now in pre-scale we're at 1. 8. Correct. Very good. I don't think that's good news, right? Because we won't be able to scale much if we pump in more budget. The tendency is for the ROAS to drop even further, right? But now, we'll have access to other parts of the fund. We won't just be looking at the creative or the creative metrics. We'll have access to the creative. That's it. You'll have access to to VSL metrics and checkout metrics as well in this case. Attention, play rate, the whole nine yards. So, alright, you're going to analyze all that. You'll have the play rate, the retention up to the pitch, and the checkout conversion. Certainly. How do you decide what to tweak? Is there a decision-making process, a checklist? How do you go about it? Like, I'm going to work on play rate first, or maybe retention, or maybe checkout conversion? Look, my take is this. I have a policy where I do everything I can to avoid having to mess with the offer. For me to decide to tweak a lead, it has to be something extreme. Like I'd have to be losing money because that lead is dropping off too much and so on. The business has to be sustainable. Yeah, in this scenario, you've laid out for me, what I would focus on without a shadow of a doubt is making variations of that creative. Because if the offer is giving me a 1. 8 in pre-scale, that's a decent ROAS. It's not bad. But it's a sign that the offer might not hold up at a seven-figure scale, for example. But what will perhaps breathe new life into this offer, which is most likely the case the vast majority of the time, is a variation of that creative. I would immediately start testing creative variations. I'd test at least 10 to 15 variations in format, editing, hooks, and the actual copy itself. If none of those variations increase my ROAS, or if I can't actually scale it, because sometimes that ROAS just holds steady. Maybe it hit a 1. 8 ROAS in pre-scale with a $5, 000 budget, then you bumped it up to $15, 000, and it's still sitting at 1. 8. I've had that happen to me before. But yeah, the trend really is for it to drop. Just like you said, you scale the budget and man, that ROAS goes down to 1. 6, 1. 5, even 1. 4. It'll become unsustainable, and then there are two ways to go. If you've already validated the front end at a 1. 8, then it might be time for you to start thinking about the funnel, and that's just looking at the front. A 1. 8 ROAS, considering everything upsells included, is pretty low, right? So maybe you can already start thinking about changing, I don't know, whatever gets more volume to your pitch, right? If your VSL conversion is say 1% or 1. 5%, getting more people in will solve your ROAS problem. Now a 1. 8 on the front end, man, that's actually cool. You can already think about scaling. Then you add a funnel, an upsell there that converts at 15%. And then, man, you've already got a multiple six or even seven figure offer on your hands. Provided that upsell has a good price point and you're testing different price points for it, adding order bumps. At that stage, it's really about funnel optimization. I wouldn't even think about I wouldn't change. I wouldn't touch a single thing in an offer that's giving me a 1. 8 rose in prescale. That's just the truth. These skills we're talking about here, right? It's a really cool skill set. And I don't even know if there's a name for it. I don't think it's just copy. And it's not just traffic either. Maybe the skill is something like scale management or offer management. I don't know, man. It's essentially knowing how to manage that ROAS and knowing exactly what to tweak in your funnel to improve it, you know? Maybe it's CRO, conversion rate optimization, you know? But man, the thing is, if you've put out an offer that's hitting a 1. 8 ROAS and it's a cold offer. Like, you just launched it with a single creative and one VSL and it did that. Man, you've got a good offer. That's great. News you know what I mean. Yes, because it means you're going to make some tweaks to it. Man, you're going to change the lead of the offer, right? I'll change it. I don't care. Just change the lead and screw it. Yeah, even before the lead, there are three variables you can change right away. The headline of your VSL, the autoplay, and the autoplay layout. Uh, it's the video that appears behind the autoplay, okay? Ah, yes, yes. So, man is more important than the lead. Actually, isn't the most important, okay? But it increases conversion quite a bit too, okay? Not that much. They're primary tests, right? You can do before moving a lead. Of course. What's the very first test you're going to run? The absolute first, man, is the creative. It's the beginning of the creative, the hook. Why? Because that's the most viewed part, you know? It's the first contact the lead has with your funnel, right? It's your, it's like your business card. Here's my funnel. Do you want in or not? So if you swap that out, you can pull completely different people into your funnel. Sure. After the person has gone into your funnel, what is the very first thing that they are going to see? Then, perhaps it's the pre-sell, right? That pre-sell headline is super important, just like the visuals are too. Nowadays, the image that appears on the pre-sell is super important. Fucking important. And then after that, it's the VSL page. It's going to be the headline, your play button layout, and the video behind the autoplay. Let me tell you something, okay? Because this right here, guys, are you an Alta Cupula? Did you see the A-B test I posted there? This week on WhatsApp, I saw it. That thing right there is going to be insane. I'm going to give you guys a preview here. I think this is going to be revolutionary, okay? In my opinion, I think this is what's going to make VTurb go viral. So guys, today we already have that hook feature, you know? where you put the headline in, and it keeps rotating. But now in VTurb, I have conversion tracking, so you'll be able to see your VSL sales right inside VTurb. You just set up a webhook, just pull the data from cart panda or whatever the hell you guys use over there into VTurb and it'll show up right under the sales data. And then, man, you can use these features to optimize for conversion. You'll be able to optimize those Ultra sensitive spots of your VSL, like the autoplay, uh, the headline of your video, the video behind the autoplay, the speed. I've had two speed tests so far in the beta. One client got a 27% lift. Just like that. Bro, 27% is just insane, man. That's a hell of a lot, man. Just for pressing a button, he just goes in, changes the speed, and boom. 27% saves an entire offer, man. It saves you, man. It's surreal. Not only does it save your profit, but that extra ROAS is going to allow you to scale even further. That combined with the autoplay. With the headline, I think once you put the offer in VTurb and run these tests, your conversion might even double. God willing. I want to run all those tests to put the video on the This is going to be more revolutionary than the shift to creative-led targeting. It's going to be wild. Brother, that's going to be my secret. That's what I want. That's how I'm going to expand VTurb globally, I believe. It's going to be something that's never been seen before in direct marketing. And then. You know what step two is? That's when it gets crazy. It'll be like I'll put an AI in there to generate those headlines, generate the autoplays, and then, uh, like you'll be able to generate that stuff based on your own video. I'm also going to put a term in there. If you want to use it, based on all the videos in VTurb. But to use it, you'll need to provide your data to us. To use other people's data, you'll have to provide yours too. You get it? It's going to be a win-win situation, right? It's a win-win right there. To use the VTurb AI, you'll have to give your data too so we can feed it. So that way, everyone wins. Together. It's really awesome, dude. It's really awesome. Next level would be like, the guy just hits that optimize button, boom, and then, man, it's infinite testing. Every single day, a new autoplay, just testing away, boom, boom. until you find the best converter, until you find one that conv found one that converted awesome, upload another one and keep going, and the conversion will just keep climbing because, like, it keeps learning more and more from your data. Look, there won't be a single part of the funnel you can't optimize, man. Just run the VTurb update. Man, God willing, it's going to work. The speed issue is already sorted, and autoplay has already proven itself multiple times, you know? Anyway, look, stay tuned, guys, by the- end of the year this will be out and it's going to be awesome. But man, regarding offer management, what I always tweak is the beginning. Always the lead. The autoplay stuff, like that, that's how I keep trying to push that rose up. Uh-huh, and the more that rose climbs, the better. Right, because then it allows you to scale even further. Yeah, I'm big on that too. Like, man, once you find that conversion point, and that's the hard part. Once you hit that point and your offer is already profitable, I believe minimum- tweaks can yield massive results. So just like the hook is the 80-20 of the creative, I think the lead is what has the biggest impact on the offer, just like the headline does. Because it's, like you said, the first touchpoint. Since you've already found the conversion point for everything else, the body of that offer and the offer block itself are already converting. So anything you do here that impacts your lead right off the bat is going to significantly boost your overall conversion. The conversion rate of the offer itself will likely stay the same, but you're increasing the volume of people actually getting to it. So I'm like, yeah, once you've, man, you've got an offer hitting a 1. 8 ROAS on the front. Man, those are minimal changes. Actually, I wouldn't even touch the copy or anything. I'd go straight to optimizing the funnel itself. And man, one class that really changed the game for me regarding offer management since you brought it up was a class Wakada gave in my community about AOV. How to increase your AOV. Oh, that's top bro. Man. That's really top tier. Because he showed me step by step that your upsell conversion rate isn't even the most important thing. It doesn't matter. Right? It's the, how much it adds to your final average ticket there of the-His contribution in each sale. Exactly. That's really awesome, man. That's so badass, bro. I can't even explain that time. I think people will be curious, but I just can't explain. Let me explain, man. So, it's like, the whole idea is that this, this is really good, okay, folks? If someone comes along and says, 'Dude, my upsell is amazing.' It converts at 40%. You're losing a fortune. And then I say, 'Fuck it, ma.' I mean, like, but how much money do you actually earn? How much is the-ticket. How much does it actually contribute? Like, imagine your upsell converts at 100%. Man, your upsell was made by God himself. God said, 'Man, I'm gonna write this guy's upsell.' God went in there and wrote it, and it converts at 100%. Right? But God messed up, man. He was supposed to set the price at $100, but he made a mistake. He dropped a zero, and it's only $1. He set it at $10. He set it at 'one real man.' Yeah, he really blew it, right? You'd have to fire him. Exactly what happened. What's going on, folks? Seriously, it's 100% conversion. Every front end sale will make an upsell, right? 100%. But the ticket is one real. After 100 sales, how much will you end up with? 100 reais. 100% conversion. That's one real. Now imagine he's the one who made your upsell again, but this time he really doubled down and said, 'Man, I'm gonna charge more now. I'm gonna charge a million. And he went in and put all those zeros there. He charged a million. The conversion rate dropped, right? Now the conversion is only 1%. Nothing sells. Didn't sell. Didn't sell, didn't sell. Then, after the 99th front-end sale, you hit sale number 100. Since the upsell conversion is 1%, the upsell sale went through 2. How much was the sale? A million. In the first case, you have 100. In the second, you have a million. Which one's better? Upsell 100, the other 1%. The 1% upsell is much better, as the ticket is much higher. so the secret man is having that perfect balance between conversion and price point it has to be a high ticket upsell that still converts well to really add value to your average order value. And so, about this whole thing man, for you to calculate that, right? To see how much your conversion increases, or actually how much your average ticket value goes up in your funnel, you just take the upsell conversion and multiply it by its price. It's just that there's a simple little calculation you can do. Okay, it's very easy to do, but for example, if your upsell is 100 REAs, right, and it converts at 20%, it means that, on average, every single front-end sale is bringing in an extra 20 REAs, which is that 20% multiplied by the 100 REAs upsell ticket. Guys, the ultimate metric, right, for you to know if your upsell is performing well is to see how much of a ticket boost that upsell gave you relative to your front-end price. So, if your front-end product costs 100 Rees, right, and your upsell converts at 20% at 100 Rees as well, your upsell is increasing it by 20% times 100, which is 20 Rees. These 20 Rees, compared to the 100 from the front, are 20%. So, it increases the ticket value of the front end by 20%. So, listen to what Kawe told me here, okay? Hey Juwon, just look at this. I launched an offer in the US market, and I followed the upsell secret framework. My upsell is converting at 30. 2%. He's increasing the average ticket by 48. 81%. Thiago, put the thing on the screen here for us, okay? Look at that, man. Oh. What did he say? Man, 48. 8%. So, check it out. Before, he was making 100 bucks on the front end, just chilling. Then he added the upsell, and now he's making 148 res. Before, he would spend 50 bucks to make 100, so heTotally, man. Now, his scale is on a whole other level. It's a total game changer. Now, he can actually scale up so much more, man. So, the upsell, man, oh my god, the upsell. The upsell is the one thing where you guys mess up the most, okay? You just keep messing up. It's the truth. People really neglect the rest of the funnel. You just mess everything up, man. Just, look. Yeah, man. I'm actually going to do something here. Okay, guys, I have an upsell course. How am I going to give you guys this thing? I'll find a way to get this course to you, okay? We'll put an ad or something will pop up here now. Because, man, you guys irritate me with this, you know? You seriously need to do this. Because then you-Thank me later, alright? Just talking about that Wakuda class reminded me. And Joanne was going to give you this gift. But look, man, these guys can't scale their offers, and they cancel their VTurb accounts because they have no ROI. Like, the upsell is what saves your ROI, you know? And so, man, it's a mistake not to have that. That's why I say we have to learn from the launch crowd, because those guys, you rarely see a launch without a killer upsell. You know, then you look at the numbers. The big players and the guy made two million just on the upsell alone. You know, the guy made two million just on the upsell. You know, the direct response crowd they really half-assed this stuff. It's because they have front-end Roy, right? So they get lazy there. They look down on it. Man, getting back to what we were saying, we're in the pre-scaling stage. We put in three times the budget that we used during the validation phase. And we let it run for five days, alright? Let's assume that if things go south, okay. Then we're going to, uh. We won't really know if the problem is in the creative or the VSL. Because we're still testing everything, right? So to fix that, the advice I gave was: 'Hey man, you just need to go and validate your creative a lot more. Validate it there. Put it in prescale to see what's happening.' If it doesn't pass prescale, it's likely the problem is in the VSL. Yes. My question for you is when? Right? When am I going to know? When should I kill this offer? When do I just say, 'man, this offer, it's losing me money. I'm not spending another dime on it.' One thing that happens, right, is that a lot of people waste way too much time on offers that will never scale. Precisely because of this. This whole validation period. A guy puts some money in there, spends 100 res, makes 200. Damn, I'm rich. Then he stays stuck. No, but the offer sold, the offer is validated, and so on. No, it really isn't, man. When exactly does the guy give up on the offer? Man, well, nowadays, if I test three leads on the offer and I can't save it there, don't hit a ROAS. On VSL. All right, I've moved on to the VSL optimization part. I test three leads. Nowadays, we already run that test with three leads, do the A-B test, and find the winner there. Does it already come out of the VSL factory with three leads? That's right, exactly. But then, dude, only three leads. You can test up to five, right? And it didn't work out, man. It really wasn't good. I would just discard that offer. I don't really get too attached to it. You know what? I mean, but how do you define it? Right, uh, anyway, I know people will have this question. I want to ask before we go to the last part: but how do you determine which creative will work for each lead or do you deploy all creatives to a tracking link that splits to all the leads exactly today? We do this test using the Cloaker, right? And it makes things much easier. Which one? White Rabbit. Alex's? Yeah, Alex's. Okay, everyone, the white rabbit will appear on screen. Alex's Cloaker. I think it's the most famous one that people are using the most, right? Man, I think Cloaker, it came on really strong. I think it really took over the internet. entire market because dude, it's such a solid cloaker that people just can't break it, you know? So the other cloakers out there, I think they kind of slacked off a bit. And then those guys were breaking the cloaker in two seconds to find your offer. This one is good. He's good. He's from Florida. Did you know? Yeah, from Floripa. True. He's my friend. A really good guy. Alex is an OG in the game, right? Yeah, the guy is the famous rare Japanese right we liked the story is good okay rare Japanese hey guys go to his Instagram and call him rare Japanese that whole thing is funny Oh, you lost, man. That's pretty funny, isn't it, man? When you say that crap to me, it sticks in my head. Rare Japanese. But okay. So, man, if you, if you launch with the factory offer, right? Three leads there. A link from your tracker or cloaker splitting into three versions, okay? If you want to use the VTurb AB test, you can do that too. We have a feature there that splits the VSL. The downside is, you won't be protecting your offers. But anyway, you can use it too if you want. If you're looking to invest more for protection, then you go with the Cloaker. Okay, and if it didn't validate, it didn't work out, right? I mean, you moved past the creative testing phase, you went into pre-scaling, and it didn't work, and then you added more creatives. Man, goodbye. It's over, okay? Just let it go, and don't be afraid to just toss the offer out, right? Sure, man. Just trust the process there. And look, with three leads, if you don't hit it or get a decent ROAS to even think about scaling, I think you have, like, a more generalized problem. Or maybe you You're just a bad copywriter. Probably, it is probably. So it's just going to be another problem with the offer, man. And the issue is when you test leads and you still don't hit it, man, you enter this kind of limbo where there's just so much for you to test. What are you going to change? Are you going to change the story in the copy? Are you going to change the offer block? You're going to, well, there are some metrics that can guide you. Like, if you're getting a lot of initiate checkouts, but no sales, well, then your offer block is probably bad or the post pitch isn't. People just don't have enough confidence to actually buy. Maybe it's worth testing an offer block, making it a block, a much stronger offer block, adding more bonuses, more guarantees, whatever. But look, man, you enter a limbo. Where there are so many tests to do that I don't think it's worth it. It's better to just pivot that thing, move on to another project, and, you know, start from scratch. Other than just keep on trying. Man, you'll change the story of the offer. Then you'll change, I don't know, like I said, the offer block or the mechanism. Then the guy gets obsessed with the mech. Man, but this mechanism doesn't work. And then you never get anywhere. Next thing you know, six months have passed and you're still there just trying to validate that one offer. So anyway. A period of six months, you could test 10 different offers. So look, I don't know about your experience, but I'd really like you to comment on this. Man, I didn't actually run the ads myself, right? But I have seen so many offers scale like crazy. So many, man. I've lost count. And I've seen a lot of offers. Even more so, right? Especially crappy offers. I've had Traffic Ops, a guy who was an offer factory, boom, launching tons of offers. Back then man, we'd launch offers through advertorials, which was much faster than doing a VSL. So, the math is the same thing, all equal, the ROAS and all that. Obviously secondary metrics change, but look, in the end, it's an offer that you scale. And look, I've never seen a bad offer come out of the factory and scale. Never seen it. Like, it starts with a . 8 ROAS and then scale. And you manage to optimize, and then yeah, I don't see that never, but I've definitely seen offers come out at a mediocre 1. 8 and then scale like crazy. Yeah, totally. I've seen that plenty of times. But if an offer launches with a row is of three, then brother, watch out. That's the one that's going to change your life. It'll change your life. Holy shit. Dude, I even sold more. What the hell? Is this e-commerce rose like this? I remember that. Yeah. The CPA was something like 30 res to sell for 400. Good lord, it was just surreal, surreal. Nice. And then, first month, 2. 7 million. And it just took off. Up and up, the offer grossed maybe 50 million. You know, in total. Just one single offer, man. Of course, with several, actually, one product, but with several different angles. We had Cola Egypto. Several sales messages for that same funnel, for that same product. Uh huh. But, regardless of that, man, that mechanism right there was good as hell. So it worked out perfectly. On the other hand, uh, these crappy offers, man, I've tried to optimize them so much, but it didn't work. You'd try, you'd kill yourself over it, you know, but nothing. My thinking, okay, my logic. Is that if you launch an offer on the market and it's good, meaning the mechanism is good, people will believe in that mechanism and they'll buy. The way you present that mechanism could be crappy. Sometimes the creative itself can be total trash, right? So maybe your ROAS will be a little bit lower, but people are still buying. You're still getting ROAS because people believe in the message. So if you improve that average offer and get more people to see a mechanism that they actually believe in, it's gonna scale like hell. This is just what I've seen in my experience. Well, on the other hand, if your mechanism isn't converting. If you're putting people there to see it, the ROAS is low, and people don't really buy it. Man, if you try to optimize that start, switching creatives or leads, all you're doing is showing more people a mechanism they don't believe in. So before, one person would say, 'Nah, I don't want it.' Now, instead of one, you've got 10 people saying they don't want it. We have reached a point here where the 80-20 of an offer is the mechanism. It really is, man. Because, well, the mechanism often defines what you're gonna say in the body of your ad, in your lead. In practice, the way I see it, direct response copy is about finding solid mechanisms and expressing them through good angles. That's the whole deal. Well, if you look at the offers that scaled the most both in Brazil and worldwide. It was always a mechanism that people already bought into, right? Like those superstructure mechanisms, man, like the banana trick. It's something people already believe. Where the guy can show them through A plus B that, well, he can confirm the belief that the person already has. This mechanism here is the multi-seven-figure mechanism, right? Yeah, probably. Bro, what determines if you'll scale more or less is how you build everything around that mechanism. How you present it and all that it's the math part. It's how many people are going to see that and at what cost is that going to be? That's totally it. If you show it to the whole world at a low cost, it's going to sell like crazy. Uh-huh. Direct marketing has three pillars, right? Psychology, communication, and math. The first, the most important one, is psychology, then math, and only then communication, man. Copy is the third thing, you know? Math is more important than copy. This thing about, about seeing that, the medical ticket Vakuta mentioned, it's more important than copy, because imagine, okay guys, just think for a second, use that thing called a brain in your head, and think, man, if you could show your VSL to the whole world. without any cost you would become a millionaire bro yes even with the copy being bad if your vsl said only buy this if you're an idiot who likes to eat plastic and want to lose weight. Buy it. There'd be a nutcase somewhere in the world who'd go, damn man, that's me, I'm dumb, I'm an idiot, I like plastic. Boom, he'll buy it. Serious. because, man, there are so many people in the world, dude. Someone's always going to relate to it, right? They'll be some crazy person. You know, every copy converts. Now, the question is, does this convert? Profitably, that's it. That's why the math part is key. That's why sometimes, man your copy it might even be bad but if you're running ads on Quai Ads, whatever or in some some new media that hasn't emerged yet where the CPM is very low, so attention is very cheap, and then you can get roy you know absolutely. So this is so interesting, man. It's this talk is crazy. Right. And like, it makes me think about. Why has this US affiliate market hit so hard here in Brazil? Because man, look, look at the level of the conversation we've reached here just talking about offer validation. While abroad, the guy doesn't even need to worry about that part of the funnel. You get it? So that saved like a lifetime for the guy there. Yeah, he has no idea what's going on. He's like the guy who hits a button and the light flips on, right? Like he doesn't even know what happened, but there's so much behind it to make that light work. Absolutely. The light turns on. Looks good. You get it? You're there at your house, seeing this look good. The light just came on. You don't even know how it worked. It's like the affiliate market. Like, they have the whole setup there, the mechanics, the whole damn thing, and here it makes bank. But I don't even know. Your job is just to make creatives. Create ads and drive traffic. That's it. Yeah. But man, look, we went off on a tangent here, right? But it's fine. That's just what happens. So, let's go back, okay? We passed the pre-scale. Yeah, we've already decided, right? We talked here about when we, actually, there's one last question I wrote down here, man, to kill this pre-scale part and get to the post-pre-scale phase. Can you say, man, how many tickets, right? I think we can do the math, okay? I think so. In my head at least, it's logical. How many tickets? are needed for you to give up on an offer. Have you ever actually thought about that? Tickets in what sense? Offer ticket there. The offer costs 100 reais. Oh, I get it. How many times 100 reais do we need to validate an offer? Because, like If there are three leads, right, we have ten creatives, and then, are you talking about the ticket price? Yeah, the price. Okay, man. If the offer is a hundred bucks, how much do you put in until you, to try to make it work until you say, man, I'm done with this. I understand. I get it. I think that's calculable, right? Well, about the ticket, I think. Man, that's interesting, huh? I'd never thought about it, but really, if you stop to think, you can calculate it. I'd say around 10 tickets, it's possible, you know? That with 10, I don't think so. I think it'll be more because, like, if you test 10 creatives, each one is a ticket, right? So, okay, this is just for validation. So, well, no, I'm talking about after the creative test, right? 10 tickets. We'll talk about. Oh, I see. So that makes 20. Is it 10 plus 10? So it is. Could be. Just to make it clearer, right? Like you should be able to calculate that because you assume I'll test 10 creatives. Each one is a ticket. Then in pre-scale, I'll evaluate so many creatives. Then you test something else. Yeah. I think an average number like of 20 tickets is good. Yeah, cool. I liked it, man. Look, if you tested 20 tickets on your offer, my offer is a hundred bucks. You tested two grand, it went south, man. On traffic, right? Not the VSL cost or whatever you spent. Your offer is a hundred bucks, and you spent two grand, and it went south. Then, man, move on. You know. Exactly. Are you going to stay there spending money? But man, okay, let's assume we're here, right? Let's say, no the guy, he's a good dude. He came on the podcast of, actually, he watches Escalame of I mean, Secrets of Scale. Escalame of Ferda is the other one. He watches Secrets of Scale. Nice. He's getting results here. Whatever. And he saw, man, my creative is fire. I went in with three times the budget, ran for five days. It's got a row of two here, man two and a half. Can I start scaling? You can scale. If you're out of pre-scale with a 2. 5, man, now comes the easy part, right? All the hard stuff is done. Testing creatives, isolating variables, analyzing the offer metrics in pre-scale. Man, you pass that phase. Now it's pure joy. You basically need to do two things. The first priority is to determine the most appropriate scaling structure for your offering. Nowadays, many offers scale only horizontally. And I'd say that. Man, after I read that book, what's it called? Lie with lie about something. I don't know. It's a book where you like statistics. It makes your lie true. You know, that's what I read about statistics. That's the book. Right. Lying with. Yeah. A statistics book. I guess. Man, I was shocked to say statistics like that. And people thought, 'Wow, this guy's a scam.' Huh? But I mean, I really think. I'd say that 90% of offers today cannot handle vertical scaling. Oh, yeah? Yeah, at least the offers that I run, that I've been operating, you know? Really, bro? Why? Man, I don't know if it's some platform change where, like, the moment you scale the budget, Facebook starts showing it to bad audiences. Might be something that's not actually related to the offer itself. But, Pedro, uh, can you just explain to folks, right, for the few who don't know, if some guy just got here, Ardinson, are we three hours in? If the guy's here two hours and 50 minutes in, man, he should know what horizontal and vertical scaling is. I think he knows. But he's already quit. Yeah, but just for peace of mind, man, explain to everyone what it is for those who don't know. Vertical scaling guys is when you in uh simply increase the budget of that ad set or campaign. Horizontal scaling is when you work by duplicating the ad sets or campaigns. Right? So vertical scaling, you bump the budget. Horizontal scaling, you duplicate the sets and campaigns. That's all. Okay. That's awesome. So basically what I do today before I really start putting in the budget is understanding which structure my offer works best in. So I do this scaling. Test so I call it right. So what I actually do is it's not a test. I wouldn't say it's a test because you don't need to do an actual AB test like one account with vertical scaling another with horizontal. What do I do today that's been working? First thing I say is try scaling vertically, okay? So out of pre-scale, first thing you gotta do is lateralize. So you're running five campaigns. Now in pre-scale, you'll work. I like to run up to 20 campaigns per account, right? The more lateralized, the better because you'll need daily optimization. That's the second point of scaling. So for the base of daily optimization is campaign lateralization. So. Uh, I like to run up to 20 campaigns per account for organization. And look, I've done some tests and I think Facebook, it kind of stalls the delivery when you have over 20 campaigns per account, right? I think it spends less. It gets more tied up. That's how I feel. So. I don't like running more than 20. And what do I do? I lateralize it. So. All right, area optimization, guys, is simply looking at the results of each campaign several times a day, right? So I like optimizing every two hours. Of course, always tracking sales, right? If in those two hours before then, actually, you see sales drop off. You got to optimize right then. To avoid losses. It's like day trading. And first thing I do, I don't like touching budgets on the first optimization of the day, usually at 8 a. m., because it usually spends little per campaign, so you can't really have a baseline. In the second optimization in the day, usually around 9:30 or 10 am, I already start looking at the campaigns, and then, for each of the campaigns that made more than one sale, within my ideal CPA, I'm going to scale those campaigns. And so, what do I do? I take those campaigns that sold, that have more than one conversion, two conversions within my ideal CPA. And then, let's say, I started the day with a budget of 500 per campaign or maybe 600. In that example, we were just talking about it was 600 per CBO pre-scale. Which increased three times. So you lateralize at that initial budget of 600. I was going to ask that. So, I, for scaling, I just duplicate more of what I did in pre-scale. Exactly. So in pre-scale, you ran five here, you're running 20 in my example, 20 at 600, which is man, a nice scale already. You jumped from you're at 12, 000 a day, right? Yeah, from 3, 000 to 12, 000 a day starting out, right? So cool. The campaign with two had two or more conversions at your target CPA. I start increasing the budget 10 times, meaning so. Holy shit, from 600 it goes to 6000. This scale is really aggressive. Wait a sec, man. Let me see if I got this. Like scaling, you took the pre-scale there three times the validation budget. Exactly. So then you'll multiply that by 20 times. to have 20 campaigns. If the campaign hits your CPA, will you actually put in 10 times the budget? No, if it made two or more sales within my target CPA, meaning it's out of two rows right there, for example. Just going to hit it with 2K? Damn. If it scales 100, 000 a day for this, like is too much. That's what I'd ask. You know, how do you scale so much, man? Now I get it. Well, if people want to scale up significantly, that's what they must do. That's exactly it. Holy shit, brother. But there's a few tricks to it because here's what happens. So before you write off this offer for vertical scaling, you need to do a test that I call the budget limit. Holy crap, I'm giving away all the gold here. Give it all away man, spill it, spill it man. I'm talking about a budget ceiling test bro, nobody has ever even heard of this. Exactly why we're here so uh you're gonna otherwise I'll take the box back. I'm warning you: don't take my gift away man. So look you'll start by upping the budget 10 times on campaigns within your CPA with two or more sales. Right so from 600, you went to 6, 000. Uh huh. And then you're going to monitor closely how that campaign behaves. If it's a killer offer, like a really good one, it'll keep selling in volume. Probably, if it's a six or seven-figure offer, after the bump, it'll keep the same ROAs or drop just a bit, say from two to 1. 9, 1. 8, but selling like fucking crazy. Cause man, you upped it to 6k. Uh, you know, that's across all campaigns. You check the 20, the ones with two or more sales, you hit them with 6, 000, uh, historically by default, uh, of the campaigns you start the day with. 30-40% work that day. So by the second optimization out of those 20, you'll likely have already cut 10 or 12 campaigns back in that first optimization because they didn't hit those. Two CPA's, the two ideal CPA sales, exactly. They'll already be out of your CPA. Likely campaigns that won't work that day and since you've already paused them, you're rebalancing the budget. So on one side, you're scaling. On the other, you're killing what doesn't work. That's why daily optimization boosts your profit so much. And that's why I got so much feedback from folks. Damn, man, my profit tripled without touching the offer because people just weren't doing this. They'd launch 20 campaigns and let them spend all day long. And fuck it? Fuck it. You're selling or you're not. Didn't analyze anything. But it's better than scaling a campaign while it's in the negative. At least the guy wasn't doing that, right? So. All right, you upped it to 6K. You got to keep an eye on these campaigns. Why? With a 6K budget, this thing gets way more sensitive. Man, it's just like trading. One thing to trade with 1 , 000, another thing to trade with 100 , 000. The risk of getting smoked is way higher. So you got to watch it closely and see how that campaign is going to behave. Time's going by and the campaign isn't selling. It's just not responding. And this is all based on your tracking. You're checking your tracker to see if it's converting and all that. So you really need to follow this very closely. Why? So then what do I do? The campaign, okay, it started moving out of my target CPA, out of my minimum target ROAS. I look at that campaign individually. Okay, it's below my minimum ROAS. After the budget increase, I start cutting it back by 30% at a time. Uh huh. I don't kill it off all at once. Like, if it was at $10, 000, then minus 30%, it goes to $7, 000. $7, 000 exactly. Then you're going to cut 30% off the $7, 000 again. Yes, $7, 000 again. All right, I know how it's going to turn out. Usually, when it's an offer that can handle vertical scaling, when you drop it by 30%, it starts responding again. Maybe the rose even goes up because when you lower the budget, what are you telling Facebook? You're telling it, look, fine. I like the conversions you're bringing me, but I'm finding it too expensive. You got to bring me cheaper conversions. When you drop the budget, that's exactly what you're telling Facebook. Look, the CPA is higher than I can afford to pay. And then it'll try to bring you a cheaper CPA. And often it does. And this campaign, it starts to recover. So many times in the third daily optimization, for instance, in the second you upped it, in the third you dropped it. In the fourth optimization of the day, that campaign where you cut the 30%, its ROAS might have doubled from one to the next. Because you cut it, Facebook started finding a high-quality audience, sell, sell. Its ROAS doubled. On the fourth optimization, you can up its budget again and then, um, I usually like to go back to what it was and not double it again because then it just gets crazy. Right because then we're already talking about like it's insane. Algorithms like, dude, what the fuck? Yeah, it's crazy because Facebook can't redistribute the budget for the rest of the day. Because the calculation is based on 24 hours. By the fourth optimization, it's already like like noon or one in the afternoon. So, if you're at 7K in your example and you put 14, man, Facebook won't be able to spend that. So what's it going to do? going to start spending like crazy. It'll start printing your ads. Why? Because it has to spend the budget, whether conversions are coming in or not. So the odds of it going south are huge. So, if you cut it, you just go back to where it was. So you bump it up 30%. Got it. And then you keep checking if it works, if it stays within your target ROAS. So the first optimization, we're going to set it to 10x. 10x? After that, it's this 30% up or down game, depending on the campaign's response. Right. You see, every daily optimization is based on your target min ROAS, because it's your overall target ROAS for all your campaigns. So let's say it's a 1. 8. The overall minimum ROAS it will basically base your decision on keeping a campaign that's outside your ideal minimum ROAS and making it spend more or even less. Meaning, if overall you're at 1. 8, which is your ideal minimum ROAS, within these 20 campaigns, you might have one that's below 1. 8, like 1. 6. But since the overall is 1. 8, you have margin to let it run a bit more because you'll win on volume. But are you going to reduce the budget? Lower its budget. That's why you don't kill it off right away. You let it run because it might recover and get back to 1. 8 or higher. Can it still perform even after that? Right. But even if it's under, as long as it's not losing money, in the overall volume, thinking about profit and not just ROAS. You'll be making more money because you're spending more. So it's that thing: a 1. 5 ROAS spending 200K versus a 1. 8 ROAS spending 80K. The 1. 5 is better. You play the profit game. But look, just to see if I got it. So this first optimization is crucial. This 10 times one, because if the campaign goes past that. The second one, right? This is the second. The first one, usually I don't really touch it. But what's an optimization then if you don't touch it? Why is it an optimization? Because you're just going to check the campaigns, because otherwise some slacker will just go and check at 10 in the morning. Alright, cool, so I'll take that. The second one there, I looked. Man, this campaign's hitting the ROAS I want. My target minimum ROAS, 10 times on it. Boom. Yeah. Awesome. Right. Once it hits that target ROAS by 10 a. m., there, in the second optimization, it's staying with me till the end of the day. Probably. I'll keep decreasing it there. And if it doesn't hit the ideal minimum ROAS, it'll keep dropping by 30 every two hours. Until the end of the day. Unless it's way off your target, Minroa, say it's already at 1. 3. Man, then you pause it because it's a campaign that's shown it's not going to recover. Because if it was going to recover by the very next optimization, it'd already show more sales volume. And what's the rule, like, to know the campaign won't recover in the first place? Man, if you, it always starts dropping its rows. You cut 30% and the ROAS drops even more. ROAS drops further, right? You cut 30, it drops even more. Then you kill it. So like, let's say after. After two optimizations, which is a four-hour window, right? Since we do every two. After two optimizations, the last. It just kept dropping. So kill it. Exactly. Bro, I'd be one hell of a traffic manager man right bro your mind is so analytical engineer man I'll tell you the deal okay copy is the same thing more analytic if careless fuck really it's the same thing copywriting is math So man. So I think people already got the idea of daily optimization. That's it. I got it. It's just direct response. There's just one more thing, man. That I need to clarify here. All of this, right? is From what I've gathered, based on that CBO structure, Yes. So for every validated creative, I'll have 20 campaigns. If I have five creatives, I'll need five accounts to put twenty campaigns. Uh. With each creative. Is that correct or not? Yes. See, that's one way. And I believe it's the most ideal way, which is individualizing the creatives. But that takes a lot of cash, and organization, and a contingency setup. So what I suggest folks do, which too, is at this stage, put all the the validated creatives into this CBO. Then you're not tied to running a 151 anymore, for example. If you validated three creatives, you run a 153 and let Facebook do it. So if the creative made it past pre-scaling in the actual scale, you just throw it all in and screw it. And you just stick to this game of budgets going up and down, up and down. Exactly. And this is all about vertical scaling, right? So, all right, my vertical scaling worked. I upped the budget. The offer held up. Great. Ah, is this vertical, bro? It's vertical. I thought it was horizontal because it, oh no, I thought it was a bit. No, actually, the daily optimization of the horizontal is just to pause and let the campaign run. There isn't such a big trade-off, but then it's not like that anymore. Well, okay, let's go. Let's keep moving here just so we don't lose the train of thought. Cause like, okay, you did that and it didn't work. Let's say, no man, I upped the budget and the offer stopped selling. You don't go horizontal just yet. You do what I call a budget ceiling test, because it might be that what's killing your offer is the 10 times. Is that 10 times jump? And then what do I do? All right, it didn't work today, Monday. I launched my scaling. Man, the offer started off great. 2. 0 ROAS on the first optimization. I upped the budget. Loss. What do you do the next day? You're going to cut 30% off that 10 times. Meaning instead of doing 10 times, you'll only go up seven times. So a campaign at 600, you're going to scale it seven times. So, instead of 6, 000, you'd put, how much is that? Man, I suck at math. What's the math? Sorry. 6 times 7. 6 times 7, 7 times 5, 35, 42. 4, 200 instead of 6, 000? To find your budget ceiling for the vertical scale. So, All right, cut 30%, man. It still didn't work. At seven times here, the offer's just dying. For the next day, you drop it another 30% on top of the seven. So instead of 7X minus 30%, that'll be 5X, for example. So, all right, you take the 600 and bump it up to 3000. You've run all the budget tests. Man, you'll reach a point where you'll hit a wall. You can't increase the budget anymore because it just keeps dropping. This offer just won't scale vertically. That's the most it can handle vertically. Vertical scale. Got it. Uh, okay. It stuck at five times. I bump it five times. It's still performing, man. That's great, dude. That's the ideal world. It's finding, you found your budget ceiling, you know you can only increase in the second optimization by five times the budget. Then there's another test, right? Hold on, hold on. Let me, by the way, what are you going to talk about now about the horizontal? No, it's still vertical. I mean to say Question on this. Man, the content has become incredibly technical. No, I got it. So, like, if you missed it, you'll rewatch this shit, man. It's important. Yeah, man. Great. You've managed to find the five, the five X you say you found a very important piece of info, which is what Facebook showed you that. You can scale campaigns by five times whatever budget they have. Now what you're going to test is your starting daily budget. So you want to scale big bro. You're not going to start with 600. You've seen your offer handles vertical scaling. So why, instead of starting the day at 600, don't you start at 1000 or 2000? Because then instead of five times 600, it'll be five times 2000. You'll bump that campaign to 10, 000. But then you got to watch out for something else. When you up the starting budget, you got to check your overnight sales. Because if the offer doesn't sell at night, you'll wake up with a massive loss. You can't recover during the day. And then maybe it's not the ideal world anymore. Can't you schedule it to start at 6 a. m.? Sure, but delivery changes. It gets wonky. So you always got to keep an eye on that. Man, the offer didn't sell overnight. I'm down big time, dude. Stick with the 600 there, you know? Start with a lower budget and trust the vertical scaling. Dude, this is very interesting. I like it. I'm learning a lot. Great job, man. I'm really enjoying the podcast. Thanks, dude. So, guys, if you're liking this, comment below and leave a like, alright? High-level stuff, right? I got him to spill the beans here, so it's awesome. Can I ask something about this? Sure you can. Man, you said we start at 10 times, right? To just come out scaling aggressively and all. And I don't know, man, like for me, right? In your process, then you said, 'All right.' If it fails, we drop 30 off that 10 times, so it goes 10 to 7 to 5 and so on until you hit your ceiling. Why, instead of doing that and jumping to 10 times, why don't you start from the bottom and work your way up? So, then, because then, like in theory, you'd save money, you know? You'd lose a bit of scale, but, uh, if your offer isn't that good, it's fine. Cause then, ins, you start at 2x, then 3, 4, 5. So, it hit 5, I pushed to 7, it bombed. Alright, I'll cap it at 5. It's just a way I found more efficient. Man, that's actually smarter, honestly, because See, I'm assuming someone has the cash, right? For them to burn some there. If they have the timing and timing. Yeah, I think that's it. Uh, if the guy, it depends on the company. You're right. If the guy wants scale, man, look, my company's billing big, serious. It's because you only work with heavy hitters, right? Yes, usually folks have the cash and see, since I run my own offer now I have more budget to burn, so I do it this way to save some time. But hey, guys, what Juwon said makes total sense, okay? Start with, say, 2x, 4x, 6x instead of 10 and scaling down. Yeah, if the guy lacks cash and you want to scale, that's great. Because then you'll see your total budget without losing money. You know, you see it like always profitable. Doing the opposite, you lose money, but then you lose speed. And if you have a seven-figure-a-month company or multi-figures, you want speed. It's necessary because some companies, damn, like BH or whatever, they run a ton of offers, man. Yeah, the six crew, for example, 20 offers a month. Man, those guys, they have to scale the offer as fast as possible to keep the pipeline moving, you know? But man, for the average marketer, let's say, the way you're putting it makes way more sense. Yeah, I found the way I put it interesting, but, uh. But the logic's same, right? It's different, but the idea's the same. Right. And man, this stuff is really cool, dude. Look, if, uh, there are two variables. You've got the variable of your starting budget being higher already, because when you duplicate it. Facebook's gonna respond differently. Dude, it's like Facebook. It's a wild animal, you know? Exactly. You gotta tame it all the time. You gotta be like, sort of, like, hey, do this. You're kind of there, uh, giving it some stimuli, you know? To get it to do what you want. Sometimes it won't. Then the next day, you change the stimulus. Man, it's like I say, bro, it's a trade, but a trade where you have access to all the market data. It's like, you know, Facebook tells you when that stock is going to drop, for example. I mean, it stops selling. Your rose drops, time to scale back the budget. Exactly. So you got to deal with daily optimization. That's why it's so different from e-comm. That's just not a thing there, man. Man, in Ecom, I'd launch a campaign and check it seven days later. It's right there. You know what I mean? So direct response is the Champions League of all traffic. Great stuff, man. Really good. Uh, dude, so how does it actually, uh, I got the daily optimization part down. Okay. But the scale structure part you mentioned, I don't think I quite got it, man. I don't know if you already went over it and I just missed it, but we were talking CBO structure, right? CBO. Yeah, there are times you scale with ABO or Advantage Plus 2. You said you have to test the scaling structure. How does that work? Yeah. Well, if you want to add this structure test to the pre-scale, you can. So instead of duplicating into five CBOs, you'll run six campaigns to CBO, to ABO, and to Advantage Plus. Uh huh. So in this case, I did the whole explanation here as if it were profitable in CBO. So I'm assuming that specific offer works in CBO. Yes. So I'm already scaling in CBO, and later I could run the structure test. But if you want to knock this variable out, run the prescale with the structure test. And on ABO, I know folks will ask this. They always do. Say, in CBO, you started with 603 ad sets, for example. In ABO, you'll spend the same 600, except you'll split it per ad set. So each set gets 200. So every campaign runs on the same budget. And there's an important point here. Advantage Plus campaigns, they optimize differently. So usually in the first three, four days, man, it's a guaranteed loss. They don't sell. They take longer to optimize. So uh, you'll look run the test for uh seven days, but it might be worth noting: in three days you'll already see a massive difference between CBO and ABO. Unless the offer is Killer Man, then there might be a scenario where it sells across all structures, you know, but it's been a while since I've caught a little offer like that to run. That's the ideal, right? Yes, this is ideal. Let me show my VSL offer. But, like in the first three days, you'll already see a profit difference, like a big one between ABO and CBO. So let's assume CBO was the winner. You already dropped the ABO from the structure test and stick with just CBO and Advantage Plus for the rest of the seven days. And what I see happening is that when Advantage Plus is better, it'll perform better in those days. Starting from the third, fourth day, it starts selling a ton and it starts to overtake CBO in terms of profit. But it took three days to get traction. So that's why you can't kill it sooner because you have to let Advantage Plus run for seven days to have a really solid test. Just because of that advantage plus optimization, which is different. So, all right, once you've validated this, structure stuff, just replicate the scale I mentioned. Same deal. Got it. The difference is you'll replicate the scale in the winning structure, CBO, ABO, or Advantage Plus, but with those same 20 campaigns. Fantastic. And man, this, right, like you said, is vertical scaling because we're upping the budget. Even if we run multiple campaigns, it's still vertical. So what's horizontal then? Is it 100 campaigns or what's the deal? Man, horizontal, we're assuming the offer's validated. So if it worked in vertical, it'll work in horizontal. For horizontal, you got to spread out, lateralize even more campaigns. Why? Because to hit the same level of scale as vertical, you need more. More campaigns and more accounts, right? This is where the contingency game comes in. You're going to need to spread this out both in terms of campaigns in that account and the number of accounts. So if, for example, for vertical scaling to hit a revenue scale of say 150 or 200, 000 a day. You needed three accounts in horizontal scaling. To hit that same level of scale, you're going to need 10 accounts. The gringos run it like that a lot. They're used to running with a ton of accounts. So what's the daily optimization for horizontal scaling? So you're going to launch several accounts there. In the second optimization, instead of bumping the budget 10 times or twice, you're just going to pause whatever's outside your CPA. Wait till it hits your CPA, or rather, your minimum ROAS, right? Once it hits, you pause. If it's working, even at a 10 ROAS, don't touch it. Because you've validated the offer can't handle budget bumps. Increase it, and it'll stop selling. So, man, you'll have an ad set or a campaign there at a 10 ROAS. You'll let it run with, say, 400 RIAs until the end of the day. Just let it, um. You'll be dying to increase it, but don't. It won't work. Trust me. Vertical scaling won't work because you've already validated that. Got it? Okay, man. And so what's crucial for hitting higher levels of horizontal scale is the initial budget test. And then what's going to happen? Instead of doing that 10 times test, you're going to test how much budget you'll start with on the day your offer starts the day in profit. Meaning we start with 600 from that pre-scale example. You start with 600. Cool. Uh, my offer is waking up at 8am for the first optimization, above my minimum ROAS. Let's say we, uh, set them in ROAS at 1. 8. Alright, it's waking up, man, most days I wake up and the offer is at a 2. 2 ROAS. That means you can increase that budget. So I'd increase that budget. I'd test doubling it, but you could do 30% increments day to day, not during the day. So for example, Monday, I launched my scaling day, Tuesday. the offer woke up with a 2. 2 ROAS. On Wednesday, instead of starting with 600 per campaign, I'll start with 1, 200. Then I'll see how it wakes up on Thursday. and on Friday to see if it holds. So. Alright, it stayed at a 2 ROAS. It's above my ideal minimum ROAS. I'm going to increase that starting budget one more time in all accounts. This is how you'll reach a higher level of scale in horizontal scale. Yes, I understand. But even so, people got to keep in mind that horizontal scale will scale less than vertical unless less leverage, right? It's less. Leverage like they both have pros and cons. Right, the vertical is good because you reach a higher level of scale, but it's riskier higher risk of taking a hit, like the campaign stops selling and you're in the red. While horizontal has the benefit of being a more conservative scale, except you need a bigger contingency. So that's the downside of horizontal scale. But like... One isn't better than the other. I'd say. Got it. Awesome. Man, I have two quick questions on this, alright? To wrap up the podcast, and I don't know if you want to add anything else, but these campaigns we- pause? Do we leave them there to reactivate the next day? Or do we always have to keep creating and launching new ones? Like, what's the process for creating campaigns? How does it work? Man, that's another methodology that I even coined a phrase today's Roy is today's Roy. So a campaign that's bad today might be great tomorrow, and vice versa. One that was great today could be terrible tomorrow. It'll always work on a 30% basis, meaning for every 10, 3, or 4 will work, and the next day is the same thing, but the 3 or 4 that work today won't necessarily work tomorrow. So you always need to set that campaign base you're running so you have that fixed number to start the day. So you'll always reactivate those campaigns, but then you'll uh look at them in 7, 14, 21-day windows. If at seven days it's outside your minimum ROAS, you pause and duplicate to keep that count of 20, 30, or 40 campaigns. But you never just look at that single day. I understand. You'll reactivate and reactivate and reactivate. All right, look at seven days. Oh, none are outside my minimum ROAS. Everything's good. Let them run. Then you'll check at the 14th day. So always in seven-day intervals. At 14, man, two campaigns here are way off my minimum ROAS and the CPA blown out. You duplicate them and pause those that are out. Then two new ones start. We'll have the same number of campaigns running. Awesome. And man, this might be my last question. I'll say it's this one, hands down, for real. Good. That's serious, huh? Yeah, but dude, it really is, okay? Congrats. man. Cause it's tons of traffic, tons of campaigns, things going wild. Then the chance of the creative, uh, burning out is high. Unless it's a killer creative, a beast of a creative, right? Now, on Facebook, in my experience, it burns out faster. On YouTube, I feel like creatives last longer, right? I think it's tougher to hit a winner, but it lasts longer. At least that's, and that's what I saw in my operations. How often like do you do a creative refresh? How do you go about that? So I usually say that creative. It never stops. What's going to oxygenate your offer and keep it scaling is the creative. I like to say the. Body of a creative that scales to multi-six, seven figures, rarely ever saturates. What saturates is the hook, which is the first point of contact people have with your creative. So you got to get ahead of that saturation and test an infinite variety variations of that creative hook. Wise, but then you can vary the edit format, even color some people vary, make color variations like they use the creative the same creative just in black and white. So anyway, there are dozens, hundreds of variations you can do. It's also key to validate new hooks, right? New creatives with fresh angles to reach different segments of the audience. Because, like it or not, even with a high scaling creative, you're only talking to a slice of the audience, right? Those who clicked with that specific angle or hook. So there are endless other audiences you can hit, since the sales message and the offer already convert. So it's about never stopping creative testing, because dude, once you validate an offer, your direct response operation becomes a creative operation, man. You need to, your focus is on making infinite creatives there to fucking creative. To maintain that offer scaling, that's essentially what affiliates do. Exactly. Without the pressure of the offer, right? Exactly that. Yeah, man. Man, that's why media buyers are going to be the most valued pros in this market. Because look, this affiliate market in the States, it's not a fad. It's been around since forever, since the internet began, really. And this chance for media buyers to not worry about the offer, which man is a huge deal. This whole show was about offer validation. Dude, you don't need any of that. Just nail a creative and run traffic. It's made life infinitely easier, man. So media buyer, if you're watching, you don't need a copywriter anymore. Imagine that. What a truly wonderful life this is. It's true. Now you are all truly independent, everyone. Independence? You are all free. Free from the copy. You only need to have access to good offers, right? Nice. Exactly. Yeah, dude. That's awesome, man. Listen, just one last quick question, okay? Because I think the audience might be wondering about this. I know I was. Do these new variations go straight into the scaling phase? Or do we run the full validation and pre-scaling process all over again? What's the play there? No. At that point, you don't have pre-scaling anymore. You can do it just to see if that specific variation is going to gain scaling traction. But, you know, I don't really have a strictly defined rule for it. In some cases, with certain offers, I'll redo the creative testing on those variations. In other offers, I have an account where I run this creative directly at scale. And both ways work, but it really depends on what you want to gain. If you want to save time, man, just jump straight to scale. Set up a CBO or whatever structure you're currently using and throw it in there. Or if you want to retest to ensure that creative won't make you lose money on a potential scale, redo the test. And man, I'm going to let a secret out right here. All right. The scale secret. That's it. Yeah. Since we're at it, here's another golden nugget. This is pure gold right here. Since we've already touched on horizontal scaling, guys, there is something very powerful you'll experience when lateralizing your accounts. If you take a winning creative from one account that's scaling, let's say, 100, 000 a day, and it's just performing like crazy. If you just replicate this scaling structure into a new account, it's unlikely to work. It's likely gonna be losing money every single day. And what did I do to solve that? And what really fix the issue. I redo the entire creative test on the new account that I want to run replicate or lateralize. I take all the validated creatives I have. I redo the testing structure on the new account and once it validates, that's when I replicate the scaling structure. If you start scaling on the other account right away, man, the chance of losing money is like over 100%. So this is a really cool little hack that will, you know, prevent you from losing a lot of money in this lateralization. Guys, there's only one important thing. Okay, everyone, clap it up. Congratulations, my man. Oh, thanks, Joel. Man. What a podcast, guys. Did you like it? If you didn't, man, you're missing out because damn, it's Drop some gold right there, huh? Man, so good, dude. What a lesson? So good. Congrats. Yeah, I learned a ton. Dude, I think I learned the most from this one, man. Seriously? Wow. Yeah, in terms of technical scaling details, man, it's just insane, dude. And look, everything I said here is extremely. validated by methodology and real money spent. I didn't just pull this out of my head, you know? And you know what's crazy, man? I'd heard this before, what you said, but never in detail always just surface level so I didn't know how it worked, and always from big players, dude. My top clients do exactly this, or some slight variation I didn't quite get. But I was always curious, like, what the hell are these guys doing? You know, how do they scale that much? So, dude, congrats, man. I'm truly speechless, okay? Think it's one of my favorite podcasts so far, and I hope everyone at home enjoyed it as well. But listen, man uh, thank you so much for your time. For the people at home, uh, you mentioned you have the Direct Traffic Academy right? It's TDA Direct Traffic Academy exactly. It's Direct Traffic Academy, the TDA. Alright, then you mentioned that it's closed, didn't you? What's the deal? Yeah, it's closed right now because I'm focusing on a new project launching this December. And basically, it's geared toward traffic managers. So man, all this stuff we discussed here is about offer validation. And in this product, I'm going to bring the entire US affiliate market, and how a traffic manager can start running over there. Man, it's a market where they don't have to worry about the offer, the product, after-sales, or even customer support. And I'm going to provide these validated offers, plus teach how to run them and how to make the creatives. So man, we're in the process of building maybe the largest validated offer network in Brazil. We've got international and Brazilian producers providing offers there for us. So, if you're watching and want to start in direct response, or already do it and want offer access, join me at this event on December 11th. It's going to be great. Nice. I'll try my best, okay? Guys, I'm gonna try to drop this episode early, okay? Because I want you to understand. At least check this out. I think, in my opinion, I've said it before this is the biggest opportunity I've ever seen in direct response in my career at least I've been in the market for 10 years folks and I've never seen peopleso much money as this thing that's happening now with people running traffic in the United States I've never seen it okay it's surreal it's a lot of money I confess I even feel a little bit of envy you know because if I had oh my gosh if I were in your shoes honestly for real I mean you know Imagine your expertise just making creatives These guys man Yeah these guys you see The beef all that stuff Wow Like man you guys are good but I'd destroy you dude You'd be left in the dust I'd crush it here man Forget hiring Steven's mentorship Screw that I'd get so much done No just kidding You guys are damn good. But I'd be, you know, maybe slightly similar to that. So, guys, it's really worth it. It's well worth your while to invest more in this. I think there's nothing better than starting as an affiliate because damn you don't have the part that I find most complicated which is creating the offer and having the whole setup, you know, certainly that right there simplifies everything. And you can see that the framework Pedro shared here, man, it's very step-by-step, you know, like do this, then do that. Very mechanical. It's about decisions. It's a framework. It's not like... creativity. I'm thinking of something crazy, like creating a unique mechanism. Man, knowing about stomach bacteria or white fat versus brown fat, man you know still have to structure it in all offer blocks. To still create some logical arguments. That's another approach. So, like, the guy doesn't even need to worry about that stuff. And then, in this product, I'm going to bring he'll have the opportunity to learn creatives from the best copywriters in the market, traffic with me and other top affiliates I'm bringing as well. And the cherry on top is access to validated offers, right? Yeah. Which is the most interesting part, you know exclusive closed offers. So man, this product is going to be historic. That's wonderful, man. So, dude, thanks again. Share your Instagram with the folks here. All right, guys. My Instagram is at opedrohandrade. Follow me there. I post content every now and then. There's my YouTube channel too with lots of free stuff. So follow me there. Thanks. We're in this together. All right, guys. Pedro's Instagram is going to appear on the screen at opedrohandrade. The YouTube will show up too. Do you know what your YouTube channel is? Dude, I think the handle is the same. The username is the same as Instagram. If you search for Pedro Andrade direct traffic, my channel shows up. Everyone, it'll be on the screen and also down in the description of the video, okay? So follow Pedro there and tell him, man, I came from the VTurb podcast. It was awesome. Really liked it. Great stuff. Sign up for his event when it pops up. Even if this comes out later, sign up. If there is one, you know, if there'll be a second version, but if there is, sign up there. If there isn't one, then man, find a way send a message there. Tell him you want to join whatever fuck it. Yeah, just handle it yourself. Okay. Anyway, man, I really wanted to thank you once or give a message of good vibes. Whatever you find interesting, go for it. Man, I just want to thank everyone who stayed until now. I think it was almost four hours of content. Three and a half hours, man. Yeah, I think if you're just starting in this market and don't have many results yet. Look, you've engaged with a three and a half hour podcast, and that shows you're really serious about your success. Man, I just want to say, don't quit, all right? Because the game turns around so quickly here. Today, you might have zero results, but man, a month from now, your life could already be totally changed, okay? And this direct response market is truly a field that provides you with that opportunity to change your life and change it very quickly. So just keep pushing forward on your journey. Because you will definitely be rewarded for all your hard work. You can be absolutely sure of that. Thanks, man. We're in this together. Wonderful, everyone. Just one more time. Make sure to follow Pedro on Instagram and follow VTurb too. It'll appear right here on the screen. Like the video, okay? Share it as well. It helps our channel grow. That way we can bring more guests. And become even more relevant, which is good for you too. This was another episode of Secrets of Scale. Big hug and thanks. Peace. Now, if you really enjoyed this episode today, please don't forget to hit that like button and subscribe to the VTurb channel so you can receive more of our episodes directly in your inbox. This is honestly so important for us, and if you do that, I can guarantee you that I'll bring the very best guests in the industry to share their content with you, alright? Also, if you're looking for more episodes to watch, I'm going to leave two other episodes right here, somewhere on the screen, from Secrets of Scale, for you to check out. Laters! So, go ahead and click there, check them out, give them a watch too it's definitely worth it. A big hug, and I'll see you soon.